I do think that you're arguing with a disingenuous pedant.
Far worse than theists these days, whose position I can actually respect since they know what they believe in, are militant agnostics who like to erect a little molehill of supposed moral superiority which they then proceed to climb and announce that "hey guys, we're better than all of you because we don't claim to know anything"

To which the obvious reply is "well why don't you shut the fuck up if you have nothing to say?"

Something which none of them appear to have considered is the logical outcome of their position.
(Dildo Bugger destroyed a ring on, Thu 24 May 2012, 1:18, Reply)