Eyelashes
This could have been my answer last week (I Don't Understand the Attraction) too, because I don't know why - and I can't control - my weird love of eyelashes. If cakey with makeup, or grossly elongated and curved fakes, they do nothing for me. But thick, long, natural lashes make me drool.

It always catches me by surprise - I'll be talking with someone, and suddenly notice that they have lovely lashes, and I'm smitten.

This attraction would be OK if only beautiful, fit ladies had pretty eyelahes. But, no, fat chicks and (most disturbing) guys, can have great lashes too. Creeps me right out when I find myself admiring some fellows eyelashes.
(danalan Pretty good, for an amateur., Thu 22 Oct 2009, 15:32, 4 replies)

With you there pal...
...and if she has full (not bushy or overly trimmed) eyebrows all the better.

Dear God - we are discussing the merits of female facial hair!
(Tugnut I got them all..., Thu 22 Oct 2009, 15:38, closed)

Well, I wouldn't worry..
Until you start extolling the virtues of female chest hair.
(Lythium deals in lead, my friend., Thu 22 Oct 2009, 16:25, closed)

.
Mr Anodyne has gorgeous eyelashes. If I had his eyelashes I would throw away all my mascaras. Ah...
(BelladonnaAnodyne Melissa's gonna wet herself, I swear..., Thu 22 Oct 2009, 16:40, closed)

I've got full, rich, eyelashes.
They're goddamned fantastic.

Goes well with my beard.
(Scritty Bakerman., Tue 27 Oct 2009, 10:47, closed)