You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Messageboard » XXX » Message 8110320 (Thread)

# But if such a mapping were to be created,
neuroscience would converge with psychology.
Neuroscience can be used to measure fairly crude emotions, but then, we're mostly using fairly crude equipment.
The spatial resolution just isn't good enough to take it down to the neuron level. Yet.
(, Wed 27 Feb 2008, 23:32, archived)
# It could yes
In the same way Special Relativity will eventually merge with Quantum mechanics to create a unifying theory, once they iron out the flaws in String theory. But until psychiatrist computers can scan people and give psychological analysis based on neurological activity, the mind will still be seperate regarding those schools of thought.

In human terms it is too hard for people to compute thing mentally, in the same way you calculate forces such as friction, wind resistance, water resistance and so on despite the fact they are part of the same unifying forces.
(, Wed 27 Feb 2008, 23:37, archived)
# Yes, I expect they'll always be seperate.
I hope so anyway. The alternative is worrying.
Nonetheless, whether or not we can measure them, I think that all the processes of the human 'mind' are purely physical.
(, Wed 27 Feb 2008, 23:39, archived)
# Well yes
Presuming you are using physical in the literal sense to mean energy transfers, rather than physical as in touchable. In which case everthing is physical, as everything is energy.

But we digress from the point, I grew these breasts right...
(, Wed 27 Feb 2008, 23:44, archived)
# I mean physical as in matter or energy or whatever.
Something that is physically understood, rather than something defined purely as "not being matter"
(, Wed 27 Feb 2008, 23:45, archived)
# Indeed,
I think anyone who would try to argue that the mind is anything other than some energy transfers, is a mental spiritualist. Consciousness on the other hand is more of a philosophical nightmare and also in many cases a concept rather than a firm reality.

I think if anyone ever worked consciousness out they would probably instantly fold the universe in on itself, well obviously they wouldn't, but that's just a concept on its nebulous nature.
(, Wed 27 Feb 2008, 23:51, archived)