as Joplin was a fat drunk/addict who sang other people's songs in between burgers. Hendrix was truly awful live and was unable to reproduce the same sound and riffs live as he had recorded simply because he was too fucked up to remember them. Strummer I have a lot of time for but he had a serious amount of help there and would be nobody without the likes of peter Tosh and the Sound systems of West London in the 70's.
Then Lennon and McCartney. Lennon, flawed genius ( as most are ) McCartney, leech who clearly only fed off the talent of Lennon in order to produce anything worthy.
And as for Jackson. I have no problems saying he's no genius. Fantastic talent but again, built on the backs of too many others to say he was the driving force behind his success.
(,
Thu 8 Nov 2007, 0:37,
archived)
Then Lennon and McCartney. Lennon, flawed genius ( as most are ) McCartney, leech who clearly only fed off the talent of Lennon in order to produce anything worthy.
And as for Jackson. I have no problems saying he's no genius. Fantastic talent but again, built on the backs of too many others to say he was the driving force behind his success.
but you leave me needing more.
(,
Thu 8 Nov 2007, 1:34,
archived)
but with Joplin, I felt she brought a lot of meaning to songs with the way she performed them compared to the way many songs have been since. Music has progressively lacked emotion and meaning since the sixties until it reached the antiseptic scrotal plateau of today. Hendrix didn't reproduce live what he recorded, I agree, but he was undoubtedly a genius for what he achieved in the usage of an electric guitar, he did many things that no-one had thought previously possible. And yes, with regard to McCartney, he could be seen as leeching off of a troubled genius, but McCartney along with George Martin, was the technician and the one with the musical knowledge in the Lennon&McCartney pair, which made it possible for Lennon to express himself. The questionable solo careers of the two (of which Lennon's was obviously better) is what necessitated my mention of pre-80s McCartney. With Michael Jackson... hmm... I hesitate to call him a genius in a similar way as I hesitate to call Prince a genius, but "Dangerous" are "Purple Rain" are works of brilliance
words, words, attempted justification...
(,
Thu 8 Nov 2007, 1:12,
archived)
words, words, attempted justification...