You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1609308 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post
How did physical disipline become physical assualt?

I'm in favour of both in the right circumstances.

Back in my day if you were caught stealing you'd get a thick ear from the shop keeper, and then the local bobby, and then your parents when you got home. Kids these days think they can arrange looting sprees down Oxford street via TikTok and get away with it and proably do.

What would you do if you were faced with an angry knife welding 12 year old who is threatening to cut you up and his equally demented mates got the phone camera ready to capture it for the likes and subscribes... I don't think getting down to their eye level and trying to empathise with them is going to do your health much good.
(, Thu 5 Oct 2023, 20:09, Reply)
This is a normal post your equivalences aren't equivalent
one doesn't begat the other
your debate is fallacious
you are a fucking idiot
(, Thu 5 Oct 2023, 21:15, Reply)
This is a normal post I disagree
you can bring up kids with good values without ever hitting them, and in general I've found that kids that were hit correlates with them being fucked up adults. Something about living in fear and being helpless while a trusted powerful adult beats you is a great one for harbouring festering resentment and future neurosis, thought it may help you being a city trader.
The idea that a lack of corporal discipline is responsible for modern ills is absurd, but it's one that's pushed by conservatives because it seems to offer a nostalgic simplistic solution that appeals to their base. It's similar to the idea that if there were more police and bigger punishments there would be less crime. But the opposite thing happens. The US has the death penalty and frightening incarceration rate, yet far more crime and murders than less strict countries. You look at socially cohesive low crime countries like Japan or Denmark or Bhutan, and you don't see a lot of discipline and fear. It's parents buying into and role modeling good values, and creating the expectation that their kids will also follow it. . Fear of bad consequences is not the only motivator of human behaviour, and it's a poor one to rely on.
However you do need to spend time with your kids to role model values, and that's a modern issue. Both parents working and many familes don't even have the bare minimum of sitting and watching tv together anymore. Kids have no idea what their parent think or value. So parents leave it to the schools who are useless, especially the Public schools like Eton, full of discipline, lord of the flies bullying that saw Boris have to adopt his lifelong personae to avoid, and parental abandonment, that produces the current tory ruling class. Which explains a lot
(, Thu 5 Oct 2023, 21:59, Reply)