but a referendum in one country is a different kettle of fish to a fed election in another
The brexit backers ran a highly effective social media campaign unconstrained by normal election advertising rules, where they made a series of claims that were widely shared that reality has proven to be egregious lies and gross exaggerations. It wasn't the only factor, but it was a substantial one, they had something like a 50 to 1 sharing advantage over Remain, they shit all over them on social media,, and that style of campaigning only became more sophisticated with the likes of Trump/cambridge analytica targeting.
How do you counter a lie, as in get somebody who's seen the lie repeated many times in their feed to see somebody credible make a reasonable counterargument, when, say, in a state like Queensland you have a single daily newspaper owned by Murdoch? It's a modern problem and it's only getting worse as the same forces that fund social media campaigns discourage followers from paying attention to anything but social media (Project Fear, Trumps "don't trust the MSM" and Musk's various utterances).
(, Sun 15 Oct 2023, 23:12, Reply)
My impression was very much that Leave won in spite of social media.
I just wondered where you thought the blame lay for the NZ election result. International superstar Jacinda just fucking off when the going got tough couldn’t have helped.
The US election will be won not on social media, but the televised presidential debates. Whoever appears even slightly more compos mentis will win. Trump has never uttered an even vaguely coherent sentence in his life, but Biden can’t even find his way off a stage. However, the mainstream media will say social media played a super massive part. It won’t.
(, Mon 16 Oct 2023, 2:59, Reply)
Farage’s Brexit party accounted for 51% of all shared content on UK Facebook and Twitter during the campaign, while Change UK generated 1.1% of all shares on the platform. That's a fair win.
As to the importance of social media, I think you're a little behind the times. For many people now it's their only method of hearing news and how they form opinions. they're not watching newsnight or question time or reading the telegraph. they're watching videos and memes on their phones.
As I said, I don't follow kiwi politics that closely. I know you don't like Adern for whatever reasons, probably because of the international esteem she's held in (which was less in nz but so was the dislike for her) but she won two elections, the second in a landslide, and served 6 years. But I know there's been rising cost of living, high inflation (for NZ), so I imagine the incumbents took the hit for that and any other grievances people have developed over their terms. Hipkins seemed kind of beige. the centre right were 5% short of winning power, but they've formed an alliance with ACT to get power, a weird mix of libertarian and liberal values which will be interesting how it plays out with the conservatives, though Aderns first term was with the hilarious Winston Peters and his Nationals
(, Mon 16 Oct 2023, 6:22, Reply)
I well remember the ubiquity of #PEFB but don’t recall the gammon equivalent.
“For many people” is a bit vague. Which demographics, how many people?
You’re saying mainstream media is dead, but many ‘legacy’ media organisations have massive online reach. Who’s filling their shoes?
Question Time is fucking shit, and always has been.
Newsnight covered up for Savile and then two weeks later had some guy accusing a Tory dinosaur of being a nonce. The day after the report aired a newspaper showed this guy a photo of the man he’d accused, and he said “Oh, no, sorry, that’s not him.” That’s an encapsulation of the BBC’s journalistic integrity. Another would be Martin Bashir. Nevertheless, literally millions of people in the UK consume their output every single day, how many people are seeing these memes of unknown origin?
(, Mon 16 Oct 2023, 19:50, Reply)
it correlates quite strongly with education, and that's what you see with voting. The referendum on the weekend did to. A very stark proportional trendline between education level and yes voting, as did brexit. So the trend is for uneducated people to avoid traditional news, and rely on social media to form a world view. And that's not entirely a natural phenomenon. The big money behind politics is targeting these people. These platforms sell who they are, what their education level is, what they already like and dislike, and you can push targeted campaigns in a highly sophisticated way, unconstrained by electoral advertising rules. And they're much more likely to believe misinformation because they're both uneducated and uninformed by other sources. It's a powerful and growing demographic. Look at childrens habits. Less and less sit down and watch the news with their parents, they're on the phones and they're becoming adults with these habits. Newspaper readership shrinks year on year. And the ones who stand most to benefit by an uninformed credulous public encourage rejection of traditional news sources.
As to memes, we're seeing traditional media report social media rather than leading it. There's been two social media posts over the weekend, one of israeli children being beheaded, another of child prisoners being kept in cages, that were reported around the world, and with the first claim reiterated by both Netanyahu and Biden before they both walked back from it 24 hours later. The first has no evidence, the second was a hoax photo, but both went around the world and are still being repeated as true. They had the desired affect on western public opinion. Hamas supporters have their own bullshit they're sharing
The brexit metric is from a guardian article: www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jun/29/how-brexit-party-won-euro-elections-on-social-media
It's confirmed by plenty of studies: networkconference.netstudies.org/2019Curtin/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Yan_18842588_A1_FINAL.pdf
Anyway, I'm sure we're boring other b3tans with our blather, though you did name me in the link so i figured you wanted my 2p
(, Mon 16 Oct 2023, 22:29, Reply)
“The big money” i.e. corporates and their massive marketing and advertising was unilaterally yes, and very vocal about it. The big money of national and local government was unilaterally yes.
Social media is youth driven. I literally know no one anywhere near my age that sees it as anything more than a diversion or distraction.
You equate tertiary education with intelligence. There has been a massive explosion in the number of university educated individuals but that does not mean people are more intelligent, it just means there are lot more degrees being given out. Standards of academic rigour have not risen, but fallen, simply to accommodate more paying students.
I’ll never understand why less than 4% of a population should have a privileged status (the nature and extent of which was never explained) in a democracy, it just doesn’t seem at all democratic to me. I’ll never understand why people think calling people stupid is ever going to be a vote winner. Presumably that’s because I’m stupid.
Anyway let’s call it a day, we never agree on anything. I wish you all the best.
(, Mon 16 Oct 2023, 23:10, Reply)
if you want to end it arguing against things I didn't say, I'll have my say
I didn't propose a solution (or vote winner) to the analysis I described, and education does correlate closely with voting preference in these referenda, to say that is to describe reality. the brexit campaign was much more effective in their social media engagement and shares, and social media is hugely important, I'm suprised you're trivialising it. In the uk facebook ad spend overtook all uk tv ad spending in 2018, so the companies and political parties dont share your view.
in 2019 52% of americans and 40% of britains got the majority of their news from facebook. Also 28% from youtube and 17% from twitter, and twitter users were also more likely to have twitter as the sole source of their news. I'd predict those numbers have increased in the last 4 years. Social media users were more likely to give credibility to headlines shared by their friend than by news organisation. They were also more likely to remember ordinary twitter post containing news than news organisation twitter headlines.
These things are real and measurable and people study them, whether they suit your narrative or not, or jibe with what your social circle does. It doesn't mean everyone who votes no is stupid, or that you're stupid, or that everyone who is educated is smart, (although the higher the education level the more opportunity to be taught critical thinking skills and how to assign credibility to sources, unless it's an arts degree). But when you're analysing the voting behaviour of millions of people you look at shared characteristics like age and education level, that's what the people who try to manipulate voters to get a desired result are doing
(, Tue 17 Oct 2023, 14:09, Reply)
I helped campaign for the voice to parliament, for all the good it did us. so still feeling disappointed and belligerent about it, despite you being civil and reasonable in your points
(, Wed 18 Oct 2023, 1:41, Reply)