You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1610609 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post explaining jokes doesn't make them funnier
ah i had to search for that argument from a a few year ago, it was the day the US pulled out of Kabul,but it's obviously one that's lodged firmly in your triggered mind. I didn't have the appetite or patience for dealing with your nonsense then. Like being at a funeral for some smoking relative who died of lung cancer and someone coming up and wanting to say 5g towers caused it. but if you want to bring it up...

My point was about the US invasion having so lost the battle for hearts and minds to the taliban in the afghan provinces that support for their puppet regime completely collapsed within a day of them announcing a pullout, and how that was depressingly predictable and being said by most people on the ground there for years, seems to have transmogrified in your binary brain to "cumquat thinks the taliban are good". that's your business.
As I said at the time, having been part of the stop the war movement, I found the stupid, bloody, immensely wasteful (4 trillion in public money) humiliating and predictable exit deeply depressing, If there'd been less people like you the politicians might not have chanced it in the first place but sadly there's lots of them, people who read a spectator article on how great we are as we set up classes for rich kabul women in the green zone, and then are baffled as to why most of the country started preferring the rule of law of the taliban provided to decades of our chaos and dronestrikes and indifference. They're repressive fundamentalists, but they came and provided justice in these villages if you had family members killed and your goats fucked or stolen, something the occupiers weren't doing from their forwards bases and fire missions. Maybe these things are too complex for you to grasp. Taliban = bad is your level of nuance.
"https://direct.mit.edu/isec/article/42/1/114/12167/Why-U-S-Efforts-to-Promote-the-Rule-of-Law-in
Despite losing power in 2001, the reconstituted Taliban quickly established itself as the state's fiercest judicial rival as early as 2003. Taliban justice became a centerpiece of a full-blown insurgency by 2006. Effective legal order constituted the core of the Taliban's political program, underpinned their claim to be Afghanistan's legitimate rulers, and highlighted the state justice system's failures. Taliban insurgents actively contended with the state legal system, especially outside the capital. The Taliban operated “a parallel legal system that is acknowledged by local communities as being legitimate, fair, free of bribery, swift, and enduring.” Moreover, their justice system was “easily one of the most popular and respected elements of the Taliban insurgency by local communities, especially in southern Afghanistan.” Taliban justice sought to provide what the state justice system did not: predictable, effective, legitimate, and accessible dispute resolution.
This wasn't just some academic conclusion. Most people on the ground from NGOs to soldiers were saying exactly this for fucking years, and what a massive costly confused failure the occupation was.
hilarious, hey?
(, Fri 17 Nov 2023, 23:55, Reply)