however, I do feel you should go with the Star Trek TOS Remastered maxim that the effects should look like they could have been created at the time if they'd had a better budget, and I have to say I didn't think the saucers did, they had too much fine detail and weathering that I felt they wouldn't have had they been period, they would have just sprayed them silver I reckon, but still, yes, much better than the pie dish on a string, and I LOVED the idea to make it's 'death ray' harken back to the WOTWs original visual, that was inspired!
(, Fri 20 Mar 2009, 9:43, Reply)
Though I liked the whole 50s-era saucer designs.
There's some similarly very good work on the Star Trek Motion Picture Director's Edition DVD. CGI created with the idea of making it look like it was made in the 70s. But in the end it's CGI and so it looks like it was made in the 21st century.
(, Fri 20 Mar 2009, 10:53, Reply)