You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Messageboard » XXX » Message 11357883 (Thread)

# Quote is from Alan W. Watts, regarding anti-religious zealots generally.
‘Popular logic’ is not really logic at all. True logic is a formal analytical tool with rules. ‘Popular logic’ isn’t so fussy, because it has an axe to grind, and the people it’s addressed to are not really interested in logic, only the appearance of it. It’s a fig leaf for their prejudices and projections. One example is the assertion that there can be no god because the names and numbers of gods worshipped have changed throughout history. That is not a logical conclusion by any standards, nor is it proof of anything except the ubiquity of religious beliefs and practices among humans.

The central straw-man argument he leans on relates to the nature of god(s), and his characterizations of the beliefs of religious people in that regard. Of course there are people who believe very literally in Magic Sky Dad. But that is by no means the extent of religious thought, belief, or experience, and to characterize it as such is deeply dishonest, and avoids some of the more uncomfortable questions that smart religious people tend to raise.

Full disclosure: I was raised atheist, later joined a non-theistic tradition, which I still practice. I’ve met some very smart religious people as a result of that, and have had to change my opinions about what ‘religious’ actually means, among other things. I’ve heard it said that organized religions often serve as a way for adherents to avoid real personal religious or ‘spiritual’ inquiries of their own, by transferring that responsibility to someone or something else. Such people may be conventionally Religious, but they are not usually truly religious people, in the sense that their religious practices are performative and come from dogma rather than deep personal realization.

Which leads to: what do I mean by ‘inner life’ in this instance? I mean familiarity with the voice of your own knowing - with your emotional household and its effects, with your intuitions, with your darkest and most embarrassing hopes and fears, with your delusions. It is all there in you, in all of us. An inner life begins when we observe our own inner workings without judgement.

As for compassion… I just don’t think compassion goes on a stadium tour specifically to call a certain group of people stupid. And I don’t for a second believe his intention was to persuade, either. From my perspective, it was a group celebration of being smarter than a strawman. And for Dawkins of course, a chance to cash in on the people who follow him. Ironic, that.



(, Wed 22 Dec 2021, 0:56, archived)
# you are also good
(, Wed 22 Dec 2021, 4:12, archived)