The pic at the top of this post probably took longer to get right than an average photoshop used to take me. There is no sense at all in which if you keep clicking an AI's 'generate' button long enough you'll come up with something approximating it. It is entirely the result of guided human interaction with a vast computer program for which there is no manual. The 'effort' is of a different type, but to say it offers no opportunity for a human to express themselves in an individual way does not ring true for me.
(,
Sat 7 Jan 2023, 20:17,
archived)
I've only ever played with "come up with a prompt" AIs, rather than things you can actually tweak the variables of (I am assuming it is that you are doing rather than actually playing with a bespoke data set/algorithm?). That's why I compared it to doing an image search.
Do you think you could create something that was obviously your style? Most AI art looks the same to me.
Admittedly, my argument against it is probably not very strong for "come up with a joke and illustrate it" pictures, since you probably should judge them primarily on the idea / if they are funny. That said, the Dall-E stuff got annoying fast.
(I should clarify that my comments are about the entire concept of AI art, and not intended as a personal attack!)
(,
Sat 7 Jan 2023, 21:20,
archived)
Do you think you could create something that was obviously your style? Most AI art looks the same to me.
Admittedly, my argument against it is probably not very strong for "come up with a joke and illustrate it" pictures, since you probably should judge them primarily on the idea / if they are funny. That said, the Dall-E stuff got annoying fast.
(I should clarify that my comments are about the entire concept of AI art, and not intended as a personal attack!)
But I don’t think it really applies to me, or people like me, in the way you mean. I’m barely capable in a technical artistic sense, so any style I may have had was really just a reflection of the limits of my technical abilities, further limited by the amount of time I wanted to spend on something.
I think the primary way personal style might manifest for most makers of AI images is in the curation of what’s produced. Even really interesting settings make lots of bad images, so the choice of what to use becomes part of the creative act. This is exactly analogous to traditional professional photography, where hundreds of shots might be taken with the aim of just selecting a few. A photographer’s perceived style is largely a reflection of those selections.
Having said ALL of that, I’ve always posted grotesque and creepy images here and this is just a continuation of that. I certainly don’t think of it as art, and if I’m honest I don’t really understand why it’s received any differently to something made on photoshop. It’s just some quick fun made by tinkering around on a computer.
And thanks for the clarification but I didn’t take this personally at all, I don’t think I’ve ever seen you attack anyone here. I wish I had your restraint.
(,
Sun 8 Jan 2023, 0:18,
archived)
I think the primary way personal style might manifest for most makers of AI images is in the curation of what’s produced. Even really interesting settings make lots of bad images, so the choice of what to use becomes part of the creative act. This is exactly analogous to traditional professional photography, where hundreds of shots might be taken with the aim of just selecting a few. A photographer’s perceived style is largely a reflection of those selections.
Having said ALL of that, I’ve always posted grotesque and creepy images here and this is just a continuation of that. I certainly don’t think of it as art, and if I’m honest I don’t really understand why it’s received any differently to something made on photoshop. It’s just some quick fun made by tinkering around on a computer.
And thanks for the clarification but I didn’t take this personally at all, I don’t think I’ve ever seen you attack anyone here. I wish I had your restraint.