You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Messageboard » XXX » Message 8236114 (Thread)

# why be different?
it's a great picture, but spare us the self-critiscism bollocks, it's terribly cliched.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:28, archived)
# Although
he has a point, the right cheek could do with a Touch more shading.

It's still a damn sight better than I could ever do though.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:31, archived)
# but then surely if you stop being self critical of your work you end up being indifferent to it? or just thinking it's good
critism and art go hand in hand..things are boring when everything is good.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:33, archived)
# yes
i just mean is seems disingenuous when it's appended to a post, that's all.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:35, archived)
# i like self deprication better than self loving.
and most of us do want someone to pat us on the back and go no it's great..hence we're here.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:37, archived)
# yes, i'm with you there
but i'd rather receive compliments for what i did, without fishing for compliments with empty criticism, as if people are expected to say "nooooo, don't be so silly! it's really good, don't be so hard on yourself!"

anyway, good pic. good night.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:42, archived)
# the fact
that you can't tell if someone is saying something in earnest (granted being on a messageboard doesnt help) is hardly my fault.

i DO art... i KNOW a good drawing when i see one. but i also see room for improvement, which can only be a good thing.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:40, archived)
# How long did it take you?
Out of interest. (especially as you said the beard took ages)
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:44, archived)
# ummm
well i think i started at about 5 or 6. and i stopped at maybe 11ish?

so 5 hours ish.

i draw verrrrry slowly though...
i'm a bit worried about it, cause i can't draw for shit in a hurry, and i'm hopefully doing animation next year...
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:50, archived)
# Oh cocks.
I started about the same time, only just stopped...and i'm only about half done.

Shit in a hat.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:52, archived)
# well it doesnt really matter
if at the end you come out with something totally pimping.

lemme see?
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 1:11, archived)
# You really want to see it?
I can scan it if you really want, but it's fairly dull and unfinished.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 1:15, archived)
# yeah course
scan away
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 1:17, archived)
# In my defence I didn't have any reference, so in my head the perspective and scene was more dynamic and better composed.
Although I really don't know where the time went.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 1:28, archived)
# i hate drawing out of my head
i can never figure out what would go where...

it looks nice though, cant quite make out some of the details cause of the small picture though :(

only thing i'd say is that figure diving into the right is a bit flat, yknow like too cyclindrically.

and the composition is a little confused looking, i for some reason see a horse in the mniddle there where the soldier is standing on top :)
the decrepit buildings in the background look stellar though!
but it's not finished... so get to work!
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 1:59, archived)
# just saying that constructive criticism doesn't require cueing
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:51, archived)
# as much as i appreciate what you're saying
nobody really constructively criticises on here.

when i post up stories the best i mostly get 'that's shite' which in a way is just as useless as some-one saying 'that's great'
because it doesn't explain WHY it's shit or great.

but explaining WHY a piece of art is good or bad is actually quite hard, so i guess most people can't be arsed.
which is why i mostly say nothing, because if i try to explain why i dont think a joke works or whatever i get called pretentious and condescending (case in point: cockweasle)

but thanks for liking my picture nonetheless,
my ego is thoroughly stroked :)
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:57, archived)
# as if i care about being clichéd
heh.
it's my FREAKIN MYSPACE NAME!
i don't really care about being different, i care being GOOD.
(, Mon 31 Mar 2008, 0:33, archived)