Always good.Just had two accepted in the last week and one rejected, but I'm going to argue that as it's clear the numpty didn't understand the paper...
I also got my first refereeing assignment and I had to reject the paper as it was a pile of guff.
Oh yay, academia.
At least the book's not chemistry, anyway.
(I also got my first refereeing assignment and I had to reject the paper as it was a pile of guff.
Oh yay, academia.
At least the book's not chemistry, anyway.
Colonel Boris "...a desperate Buzzfeed imitation...",
Wed 22 Oct 2008, 19:53,
archived)
They don't send me papers to referee anymoreI delayed too much on one because they were attacking my friends, then kept telling another journal that I was away from the office for weeks and had to decline. Which was true. They just have a habit of sending me stuff to referee just before I go away.
Edit: Congrats on the papers, by the way. I'm lucky if I manage one paper a year, let alone three a week...
(Edit: Congrats on the papers, by the way. I'm lucky if I manage one paper a year, let alone three a week...
boris the spider,
Wed 22 Oct 2008, 19:55,
archived)
It's been a bumper weekAnd I've been collaborating like a Frenchman. And one of the papers took five months to be reviewed by a single referee who accepted it as is.
Go figure...
(Go figure...
Colonel Boris "...a desperate Buzzfeed imitation...",
Wed 22 Oct 2008, 20:00,
archived)