You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Messageboard » XXX » Message 9558261 (Thread)

# Yeah, but
Why won't it move?
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:21, archived)
# Because the fan generating the wind is effectivly part of the same object
Imagine you are standing on an L-shaped piece of wood and push against the vertical piece, no matter how hard you push, it will never move along the floor. No with the same piece of wood, you get off and move to the other side of the particle piece, now you can push it along. Imagine the fan being attached to the ship being like you stood on the wood
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:24, archived)
# Yeah, but
The fan would blow the sails.
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:27, archived)
# Yes it would, just like the wood would bend a bit
are you winding me up? :|
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:30, archived)
# Get Rob to put it in the newsletter
someone is bound to know the answer.

More likely you'll get 50 conflicting answers and a treatise on sponge cake, but hey, that's interwebs.
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:37, archived)
# Hang on - I've worked it out.
You'd need to have the fan in another boat tied behind you on a piece of string.
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:40, archived)
# If the rope started out slack, then it would work in a way
for a time at least
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:42, archived)
# a special string made from the queen's butt's hair should do the job
please test and let us know
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:43, archived)
# It would act like an aircraft propellor
and push the boat in the opposite direction. If it did fill the sail on the other boat it would then cancel itself out. Then the tide would get both boats and smash them on the reef, leaving you only with several records you brought along, a bible and 450 metric tonnes of Battenburg cake.
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:48, archived)
# would it not technically move very very slowly
due to the propeller acting against, in essence, the earth's atmosphere (and indeed in no way because of the sail)?

assuming there is no wind, an external power source would be rotating the propeller, forcing air to move in one direction. assuming the sea/boat boundary is frictionless, the boat would move. essentially you'd have a crap, low-flying aeroplane.

edit: the difference between your l-shaped example and the fan is that the fan acts on the system outside of the boat. obviously you'd need a big fan :)
(, Thu 2 Jul 2009, 12:32, archived)