almost everything he's released sounds like muck :(plus, you might equally hate the songs of his that i think are actually good... :)
(
boris the spider,
Fri 20 Nov 2009, 17:17,
archived)
The Libertines were utter fucking win.Babyshambles, although I like them, I can admit are pretty poor.
(
Redsushi! Whoop! Whoop! Yes, that one!,
Fri 20 Nov 2009, 17:23,
archived)
This is my opinion in a nutshellLibertines
==========
Up the Bracket = Fantastic
Various Libertines sessions (ie Legs 11, Babyshambles sessions, French sessions, some outtakes) = Fantastic
Most Libertines B sides (excluding shit like Sally Brown) = Fantastic
The Libertines = Fantastic songs ruined by an incompetent producer and Pete Doherty being shit
Babyshambles
============
Killamangiro = Fantastic
Down in Albion = Decent songs (and some fantastic ones) ruined by an incompetent producer, Pete Doherty being shit, and a really, really poor backing band
Shotter's Nation = Way better than people seem to reckon
Doherty Solo
============
Various sessions = really quite good, Acousticalullaby in particular
Grace/whateverfuckingstupidnameithad = Surprisingly good
Dirty Pretty Things
===================
Waterloo to Anywhere = Actually a really good, if uninspired, album, but a let-down because some of Carl's songs in the Libertines were exceptional
This summary of early-mid 90s indie was brought to you by Boring Boris Productions.
Edit: By "early-mid 90s" I clearly do not mean "early-mid 90s", I mean "early-mid 00s".
(==========
Up the Bracket = Fantastic
Various Libertines sessions (ie Legs 11, Babyshambles sessions, French sessions, some outtakes) = Fantastic
Most Libertines B sides (excluding shit like Sally Brown) = Fantastic
The Libertines = Fantastic songs ruined by an incompetent producer and Pete Doherty being shit
Babyshambles
============
Killamangiro = Fantastic
Down in Albion = Decent songs (and some fantastic ones) ruined by an incompetent producer, Pete Doherty being shit, and a really, really poor backing band
Shotter's Nation = Way better than people seem to reckon
Doherty Solo
============
Various sessions = really quite good, Acousticalullaby in particular
Grace/whateverfuckingstupidnameithad = Surprisingly good
Dirty Pretty Things
===================
Waterloo to Anywhere = Actually a really good, if uninspired, album, but a let-down because some of Carl's songs in the Libertines were exceptional
This summary of early-mid 90s indie was brought to you by Boring Boris Productions.
Edit: By "early-mid 90s" I clearly do not mean "early-mid 90s", I mean "early-mid 00s".
boris the spider,
Fri 20 Nov 2009, 17:34,
archived)
Ha ha ha!Yep, I concur almost wholeheartedly :D
( Redsushi! Whoop! Whoop! Yes, that one!,
Fri 20 Nov 2009, 17:35,
archived)