Anyway. As usual, you've completely missed the point. Again.
I'm not suggesting that we shouldn't invest in renewables. I'm suggesting that going by Yvette Cooper's hilariously incompetent interview on 5 Live yesterday, Labour's current climate pledge isn't financially sustainable in the slightest. To the point that Yvette herself refused to declare confidence in it and seemed to evade any questions relating to its credibility with "Aren't the Tories awful, though?!"
Holding a GE right now would be disastrous, because the vast majority of fuckwits (and they are fuckwits, just look at the Brexit vote) will vote Labour not on the strength or practicality of their manifesto, but purely because the Tories have been a particular fucking embarrassment of late.
That's probably reason enough for at least two of the most vocally Left retards on here. But personally, I'm more inclined to vote for a party based upon that party's strengths, not their opponent's weaknesses.
The Tories being fucking terrible doesn't magically make Labour any better. And let's be real for a moment, if it wasn't for Truss's utter incompetence, most of us wouldn't be looking twice at Starmer.
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 9:39, Reply)
You'll be voting Green or Lib Dem then.
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 10:55, Reply)
Thanks to the proliferation of social media and our increasing desire to mimic the 'merkins, we're basically a two party state these days, and I'm under no illusions that voting Lib Dem is technically a wasted vote. But it's still better than abstaining.
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 11:31, Reply)
in my country the states are fairly autonomous with power. The two states that invested the most heavily in renewables in the last few years and have the highest percentage , SA and Tasmania, now have the lowest wholesale electricity prices despite the other states having abundant coal and gas. SA built the worlds largest lithium ion battery storage farm. Conservatives called them loonies and fiscally irresponsible at the time. I believe "ideology and idiocy in equal measure" . was the quote from the then tory prime minister, which people like yourself no doubt parroted.
It was already profitable in it's second year, serving a huge wind farm investment. Then Putin invaded the ukraine.
I dont see hilarious incompetence. I see a tory voter who when faced with the predictable shitty reality of of supporting them, tries to invent an equivalence in the alternative that will make him seem less culpable for his folly. "See, labour would have been just as bad in my self-justifying imagination". I cant speak for all their policies. but this is a damn good one that would pay long term dividends to Britain, even putting aside the fact we're on a burning planet. If putin and now the saudis holding global fossil fuel dependent consumers hostage and causing spiralling energy price inflation hasnt convinced you, perhaps you need to think harder about who the fuckwit is here
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 12:02, Reply)
How do the populations of South Australia and Tasmania compare to the UK? I suspect it's a lot easier to invest in and implement renewable energy infrastructure when you're basically only supplying Glasgow.
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 12:31, Reply)
not the fact that the tory claims of fiscal irresponsibility at the time mirrored your own, claims that were later proved baseless scaremongering of what turned out to be shrewd and far-sighted investment?
Not the fact that SA was able to produce electricity cheaper in 2021 than my state Victoria, that has the worlds second largest brown coal deposits and heaps of existing plants and infrastructure, not to mention that it created in that state a thriving hi tech renewable power industry that has outstripped a moribund coal and gas industry in terms of jobs, so much so that in the last SA state election even the tories supported it?
No, you clutch at straws. A difference in scale invalidates the entire argument! That'll do. It's not possible that labour might be proposing something hugely beneficial. That would blow a fuse in your head. As you said, anything would be better than voting labour, and you've got the anything you voted for
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 13:21, Reply)
I know this is b3ta, and as another user said recently, not really about politics, or about me persuading you of anything in particular. But I see such tribalism as why people keep supporting things outside their self interest, and occasionally allow myself the self-indulgence of reconfirming it by engaging in such futile arguments. Sometimes I do it just to find out what counter arguments the other people are using to lazily save me trawling though twitter or the Telegraph comments. I’m honestly trying to cut down.
I think the investment is one of the few good ideas they’ve had in recent years that will improve people’s lives, and could make a much longer and far more boring argument as to why which I’ll spare you. but it’s fine if you disagree
(, Sat 15 Oct 2022, 20:18, Reply)