Science giving philosophy a kicking.
(, Sat 22 Oct 2022, 23:46, Reply)
I suspect it is a matter of scale, at the most reductionist particle level, easy no; at a human scale it is just unclear, but still no.
Our thoughts and feelings still belong to us, just not entirely our choice.
As she said, we can interfere with the process, not control it.
Anyway, I shouldn't continue, it's illegal to drink and derive.
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 0:14, Reply)
if you define free will as as a quasi-religious First Cause, that is, some Aquinas mysticism of something not being dependent on other things, then of course it doesn't exist. The concept is absurd.
If, however we define it based on delayed rather than near instantaneous decision making, and if the frontal lobe is overriding impulses coming from other parts of the brain, it's a more interesting and serviceable definition of free will.
A lot of recent brain research seems to show we're not nearly as rational as we thought we were, especially brexitters
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 4:07, Reply)
Ultimately there will be inherent time delays between decision making structures in the brain, which bit fires first.
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 5:17, Reply)
and the higher order frontal lobes fire up after that and invent a justification for the decision that brain had already made, giving the person a comforting and convincing misapprehension that they'd come to the decision through rational thought.
www.nature.com/articles/news.2008.751
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 10:12, Reply)
Not rationality as claimed or confabulated afterwards.
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 18:16, Reply)
The deterministic view of big bang onwards and saying particles behave in fixed ways ignores one of the fundamental tenets of quantum mechanics. We are not made of particles, we are made of probability waveforms, and their interaction is probabilistic not predetermined.
As this is the basis for her entire argument, the rest of the house of cards falls.
Whether it matters or not is another question.
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 9:14, Reply)
assuming that it's a fundamental property of the universe and not simply our monkey brain limitations seems a bit hubristic. I dont think we can give a precise location of the next tory leader, just that it's probable it'll be in the orbit of some shitfuckery.
Every electron, (or probabilistic wave density function if that floats your boat), that we've ever identified and measured has identical mass, charge, and spin, so I reckon there just one of them in the universe but it gets around.a lot
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 10:31, Reply)
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 18:27, Reply)
(, Sun 23 Oct 2022, 14:17, Reply)

