If he's suggesting
that the world of science makes no distinction between:
8 pulses of sound at the same frequency
and
8 pulses of sound at completely different frequencies
then he is an idiot.
I have a good friend who considers herself "amusical". Although she will tell you that she just "doesn't get" music, she'll never try to argue that we're all victims of some "emperor's new clothes" scam.
The author of that essay seems very bitter to me.
(
blindmelon, Fri 13 Mar 2009, 18:00,
Reply)
There are endless ways that one could explain how that tract of text
is a complete nonsense, but it really isn't worth the effort. That person is obviously a moron of the highest calibre.
(, Fri 13 Mar 2009, 18:10, Reply)