I'm still dubious.
"The charging spots will keep the batteries topped off with power so that they always have 100 miles of driving capacity. They are located where you work, live, shop and dine in parking lots so that an electric car will have the ability to recharge when the software instructs it to top off."
That's the bit I mean; our grid would not cope.
A better route would be developing solar power to power the car direct, surely? then no need for the charging points everywhere?
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:05, Reply)
to be honest, I see Shai as a bit of a revolutionary thinker rather than someone with actual practical answers.
But at least he's someone who's brave/stupid/rich/crazy enough to put money into it and see what happens.
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:08, Reply)
it is essential that people look at solutions, and this one isn't the maddest by far.
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:17, Reply)
and yeah yeah, evil zionists, blah blah, but aside from that:
I was in the South, allow me to put this into perspective for you:
jaxo.50webs.com/images/israel_scn.png
You see that zombie-coloured bit at the bottom? The vast majority of Israel is Desert, it's known as hanegev in Hebrew and alnaqab in Arabic, you'll usually see it in English as Negev. Preamble aside, I was volunteering on a Kibbutz down in the South, it was hot, it was dry, it was dusty, it was... well... a desert to be quite frankly honest.
They were irrigating it with water from the water table beneath the surface, there's a lot of debate over the ethics of that, people saying they should bring water in from the North, the Mediterranean or the gulf of Aqaba and then desalinate that, however, of course, energy issues with that level of desalination. Now I'm afraid I don't have the quote to hand right now, but David Ben Gurion was hot for the Negev and the tremendous amount of radiation that's smacked down on it daily; he's buried on a spot that overlooks this:
upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/8/80/Zin_Valley_in_the_Negev_Desert_of_Israel_2.jpg/800px-Zin_Valley_in_the_Negev_Desert_of_Israel_2.jpg
Now, to put this back into context; the water is heated generally using solar panels, nothing complicated, just conductors of heat with oil or water running through them (the other form aren't that efficient, at the moment, and a few years ago, at least, they took more energy to make than they produced), but what really stood out to me was that the ambulance on this kibbutz was electric! And in this case it could work, as the medical centre was a couple of kibbutzim down the road or at worse in the city of Eilat a little bit further down. When it comes to it being efficient it needs to be a localised thing, peer-led, as well. It was the people who lived in this region who opted for the ambulance and for the medical infrastructure they use (they're also hot on direct democracy).
So, this is a really long winded way of saying as long as things are local and co-ordinated it's doable. It has to be organised from the ground level up, you just can't have a government of a country the size of the UK trying to impliment it overnight, 'cos as you said above by the time they've done it it'll all be obsolete.
So, in effect, Israel is attempting to pull off this massive cock that was mentioned above.
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:18, Reply)
I guess I could imagine a city setting up its own network as an example, and then others following on.
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:27, Reply)
But to save the planet, we need a global solution, and to get manufacturers on board, it needs to be a global answer.
There is no way the company I worked for would have got involved in a vehicle that could only be used/sold in one area. They WANTED 4x4s on the school-run as well as the fields. They NEEDED cars that could pass a safety or emissions test in every country in the world.
4. Profit!
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:31, Reply)
I suppose I forgot to mention that Kibbutz is Hebrew for 'Collective' and a lot of Israelis are still somewhat socialist. They've embraced the free market and privatisation, but there's still the bus company, the milk company, etc.; heavily regulated monopolies.
Which is further intriguing, considering how they'll be living practically in a state of anarchy one minute and then using state-regulated infrastructure the next.
You can either:
1. Nationalise
2. Regulate
3. Influence the consumer.
3 seems most likely; and is what is happening, what with all these adverts screaming "LOOK, WE IS GREEN, GREEN IS FLUFF, BUY OUR STUFFS!"
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 16:38, Reply)