There's no use looking for "real definitions" of these things, they just are there by common consent. There's no higher power to appeal to.
Also he's simply wrong about a number of things. the "officer" in Police Officer does not come from CEO, for example. That's just ridiculous.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 12:15, Reply)
(Middle English, from Old French officier, from Medieval Latin officrius, from Latin officium, service, duty;) ..pretty sure he didnt say it "comes from the term officer in CEO" it was to point out they are used in the same context and legal language..I think was that point.
As for common consent....is it consent if you dont know that you consented in the first place....or are unaware of what you are consenting to?
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 12:45, Reply)
Which, even from that definition, you can see is bollocks.
There's a much better description with etymology on wiktionary, which shows he's engaging in ill-informed semantics.
It's a small point, but just a small example of the many mistakes that litter the piece.
It is consent if you don't know you've consented. English-speakers all consent to use the same language with the same definition of the word 'officer' for example.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 12:54, Reply)
Were discussing the definitions of words in Legalese, not English.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 15:35, Reply)