How can we say existence is preferable to non-existence, for the thing that wouldn't exist and so wouldn't know it didn't exist so wouldn't have an opinion on the matter?
There are lots of things that don't exist - we can't say if it's better or not that they don't exist, and they definitely can't.
If we're assuming that all life is good, and all existence is good (and preferable to non-existence), does it not follow that the suitable comparison/reference point/benchmark is things that exist? In which case, we say Jock McScroty lived an awful life, not as good as William T McRichandcleverman, but we can't say for certain that Mr McScroty would have been better off never having existed at all? But from the point of view of Mr McRichandcleverman, Mr McScroty's life was not worth it.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 12:15, Reply)
I ended up doing some work.
The test is whether a life is burdensome. Presumably, there could be at least some conditions that'd mean that it's better not to be alive (and people reach that kind of decision all the time). Presumably, too, there are conditions that might be so appalling that, whatever good points there are in a life, it would still turn out to have been better not to have lived it at all. (That is: we can imagine a welfare scale between 1 and -1, where zero represents nothing good or bad. Most lives will have a positive welfare score - they'll be worth living - but some might have a negative one. Death, being the absence of any sensation, scores zero by default - and therefore might be better than certain terrible lives. Not existing at all would also be zero, so might also be better than certain (potential) lives.)
Now, if you could reasonably predict that a new life would be that burdensome, then it might well be better for that life never to be lived, since there'll be less unnecessary suffering that way. Welfare score of zero rather than minus-something.) However, the point remains that there are very few lives that are so terrible - and so predictably terrible - that it is better for them never to begin.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 13:05, Reply)