b3ta.com qotw
You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Question of the Week » Vandalism » Post 907510 | Search
This is a question Vandalism

I got a load of chalk, felt-tip markers and paint from friends one Christmas in a thinly-veiled attempt to get me involved with their plan to vandalise the toilets at the local park. My downfall: Signing my name. Tell us your stories of anti-social behaviour.

Thanks to Bamboo Steamer for the suggestion

(, Thu 7 Oct 2010, 12:10)
Pages: Latest, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, ... 1

« Go Back | See The Full Thread

Hmm
I would argue with that.

"One" isn't a personal pronoun, it's just a noun that people use to construct sentences (using standard rules) to talk about themselves, so shouldn't (to me) have a corresponding possessive pronoun or possessive adjective/determiner.

You could substitute "Jim" or "the postman" or "Cthulhu" for "one" and you wouldn't have to change the syntax at all in whatever new sentence you decided to come up with. That's certainly not the case with any personal pronoun.
(, Tue 12 Oct 2010, 11:57, 1 reply)
There does seem to be a lot of confusion about 'one'.
When I use it, I think of it as a first, second and third person plural pronoun- I use it to mean everyone- yet I know some people use it as a first person singular pronoun.

Luckily for me, next week I'll be drinking with people who care about this sort of thing again, and I think I have a topic for our first conversation.
(, Tue 12 Oct 2010, 12:12, closed)
Hmmm
Further research would seem to indicate that "one" is a pronoun, albeit one that doesn't fit the usual rules.

So I may have been talking out of my arse. The apostrophe is correct though.
(, Tue 12 Oct 2010, 12:26, closed)
So we're back to the question of why it takes an apostrophe.
I agree that it does. As I said, I looked it up in Swan's, and as far as I'm concerned, that's good enough for me.

I just feel there should be a genitive declension without the apostrophe.

It seems my post at the bottom of the page isn't the end of it after all.
(, Tue 12 Oct 2010, 12:35, closed)
Indeed
And you would appear to have some grounds from to argue your case.

Initially I thought you were a raving loon for thinking that "one" was akin to the "real" personal pronouns, but the more I think of it, it does kind of fit in with the rest:

I/me/my/mine
You/you/your/yours
He/him/his/his
It/it/its/its
One/one/ones/ones

Interesting.

Maybe it's because it's a fairly modern thing, and was added to the list a long time after Old/Middle English?
(, Tue 12 Oct 2010, 13:35, closed)
GRAMMAR NAZI'S'S'.

(, Tue 12 Oct 2010, 15:33, closed)

« Go Back | See The Full Thread

Pages: Latest, 16, 15, 14, 13, 12, ... 1