Yes yes, I understand all of that.
But lets be honest here:

Most goth girls are fat and a mess. You can't beat facts, can you?
( Bud Muhnquai Update your profile or fuck off, Tue 26 Aug 2008, 17:29, archived)

From the overwhelming evidence I've seen:
yes.

Most of the skinny ones are more emo-ey.
( spangolin - the odds are good but the goods are odd, Tue 26 Aug 2008, 17:34, archived)