You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Messageboard » XXX » Message 7737874 (Thread)

# oh please
even you must agree that the Turner needs to find a new direction and even if this means accepting art for what it should be ( talent ) rather than some bint who thinks welding bits of discarded perambulator together is art then it's a step in the right direction, even if that direction is not entirely forward?
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:08, archived)
# not as bad this asshole
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:09, archived)
# Pffft
"art", "talent", it all sounds fine until you try to define your terms. Most people who talk about art are really referring to their own little version of what that means, in which case they're usually railing aginst everything that falls outside it.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:12, archived)
# No, I think most people who talk about art are talking about everything that falls outside some imaginary straw man's little conception of what art means.
And that's worse.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:16, archived)
# I used to wonder, but as I get older I realise that it's not true.
If you give a group of critics and artists a pile of images and they divide them up in order of preference, you'll get a huge statistical bias.

Whilst the orders will be very different, there will emerge an obvious pattern, in that they'll largely divide the works into the same category of 'art' and 'dross'.

The digital age is conning the elderly a little, but I think that it's something one picks up and maybe learns, but that it isn't learning the rules, it's more like learning which running shoe is best. For marathon runners it is very obvious, but for hanging around the house the difference is not obvious and it is only really by going out and running that one gets a feel for the difference, although the difference is immense.

Shoes may have been an awful analogy.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:24, archived)
# OK, while I agree that the art world is focussed on *something*
that something is usually the concept or the process, or both. This drowns out the ingenuity of communication*, which is what I think you may have meant by "talent" earlier.
*using some really stupid medium like abandoned shower-heads or torn-up questionnaires does not count as ingenuity. It's got to build on established knowledge in small increments.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:33, archived)
# DISCUSSION IS ABOUT WHOSE PINKIES HOLD OUT LONGEST
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:34, archived)
# AT LAST
SOMETHING I CAN GENUINELY CONTRIBUTE TO.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:58, archived)
# I can define what I think.
I think art is something which makes me think. Whether it makes me sad or happy or insightive I don't know, but it makes me think.

Craft is making a picture of a lake.

It's confusing because, before the camera, art was very different, but it has changed and, just as the planets and tilt shifts we make are not art, but craft (or filters Vs. vectors) the traditional water colour can sadly fuck off.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:31, archived)
# God
I see this entire subject in such a completely different way to that. I think it's simpler than people make out.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:36, archived)
# It's just generally unimportant
I like pictures. I look at pictures. Sometimes it's important to me. The talk just ties you up in knots and wastes your attention.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:43, archived)
# ^this!
if I like something I like it

if I think it's poo, then it's poo

but who cares, we're all doomed :)
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:44, archived)
# Pinning down a definition is an intractable waste of time when we all know what the thing is anyway.
In the case of art, though, we don't agree, and I think the art world is a bit deluded. So "I like pictures" is a cop-out.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:47, archived)
# The whole discussion is just an intellectual circle jerk
it has not point other than some one is right at the end of it.

The word has just grown away from any possible, universally agreed upon definition to hold it and really who really gives a fuck that this has happened.

It seems to me the most important things in life can't be held by words because we've all been talking about them so much that the cage has broken.

God, love, and art mean absolutely nothing in any objective way we can pedanticly pin down for a neat entry in the dicitonary. There's no third person for these things, there's only direct address.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:52, archived)
# Don't discount a whole discussion as useless
just because many participants are pseudish.
I want to make good art, so I need ideas about what good art is, and what isn't art.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:56, archived)
# Let's hear it then.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:43, archived)
# The picture of the lake
has obvious produced a lot of thought in you.

And do you think only when you're looking at art?
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:37, archived)
# I think that I'd have to go with 'Yes,'
although you are unlikely to enjoy any diatribe I might venture on the holistic and encompassing nature of art.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 1:13, archived)
# I agree
and hope I'm a little more attuned than that but I certainly will not decry what you say.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:41, archived)
# I agree to some extent,
the artists this year are all meritous, but the choice of pieces for the nominations are poor, politically.

Putting Sleeper up against Zarina whatsit must have been designed purely to draw ridicule from the Mail brigade.

It annoys me as I really rate her work, but she looks to be set as the straight man in an comedy of farce.
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:17, archived)
# I agree entirely
I'm no artist. I've always been a guy who has a talent for mimicry and I make things that I like with the tools I have. I'm never going to win prizes but I know I'm not shit.
Take this for example.

Click for bigger (396KB)
I'm quite proud of it yet it is entirely digitally produced ( via software that does it's best to mimic the use of real media ) I know it's not a great piece of art yet I'm having it printed to artboard to put on my wall. I like it. I don't think that anyone can say that it is less worthy of merit than a turd in a bed or some scrap welded together?
(, Sat 27 Oct 2007, 0:55, archived)