You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Messageboard » XXX » Message 8187796 (Thread)

# Because Science should always be open to new possibilities and new theories,
without prejudice
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:42, archived)
# like invisible friends?
oh please, leave your bible at the b3ta door.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:45, archived)
# There's a constraint on that, though...
...inasmuch as the possibilities have to be plausible. There's no virtue in believing just anything.

I think there's a line by or about GK Chesterton, along the lines that he was so open-minded that his brains had fallen out. Amen to that, brother!
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:46, archived)
# Half of the things considered by Quantum Mechanics are barely plausible by everyday standards.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:48, archived)
# but 'barely plausible'
is still 100% better than 'ridiculously impossible'
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:50, archived)
# And yet billions of people around the world believe the ridiculously impossible,
far more than would accept, say, string theory, or the many worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:52, archived)
# Now I'm completely lost
Are you saying that a theory about the world is true or false by virtue of how many people believe it rather than by virtue of how well it describes the world?

That's a funny way to go about things.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:55, archived)
# Of course not, I'm trying to point out that many of the things that Science does consider can hardly be seen as more plausible than the existence of some kind of God.
But anyway, this isn't my main problem with Dawkins, that's down here www.b3ta.com/board/8187836
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:57, archived)
# ...
I agree with you on that one - I've said somewhere else in this contretemps that he should drop the moral philosophy and leave that to the moral philosophers.

I'm no scientist, nor could I pass as one. That's his strength. But being a good biologist doesn't make you a good philosopher, any more than my being a (passable) moral philosopher makes me a biologist.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:00, archived)
# I studied Physics with Philosophy at university,
so this is always an interesting argument for me. Also, my mother is a Christian and it's done her absolutely no harm, and I consider her to be perfectly reasonable.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:02, archived)
# ...
Reasonable people can have untenable beliefs - it'd be hard to insist that one must have only true beliefs to be reasonable. Moreover, people can be reasonable in respect of most things, but not others. Anyone who's ever been in love can understand that.

Where did you do your philosophy, btw?
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:06, archived)
# I was at Manchester.
It was only a third of my degree though, so I can't claim to have much more than a basic grounding in it.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:08, archived)
# Oooh...
I'm teaching ethics in Manchester now, albeit the law school. Who taught you what?
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:12, archived)
# I'm trying hard to remember names but struggling.
My main ethics teacher may have been called Cohen...fairly old, and looks just like a classical Greek philosopher, beard and all.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:20, archived)
# Harry Lesser?
I'm scratching my head a bit... I don't know the philosophy department all that well.

Plus, I think it's home-time...
See y'all tomorrow!
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:21, archived)
# Ah yes, that's right.
I only finished last year, but I seem to have forgotten all of their names already.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:23, archived)
# I'm a biologist
and I took one module of Philosophy* at universtiy, so I'm sorted.

P.
*I failed it
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:05, archived)
# because billions of people around the world
are ill-educated and living in a system still controlled by a few espousing an archaic belief system. Indoctrination into any faith will soon make a believer of most people who don't have the chance to expand their minds beyond it. You should know this and it upsets me you would argue for a church yet still bother to educate yourself.
If your faith is enough you don't need self-betterment.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:26, archived)
# I'm not religious, I'm not arguing for myself.
As I've said elsewhere in this thread, my mother and various other people I know do believe.
I don't see this as a fault with them, I see it as their decision. They're not hurting anyone, it helps them, why take offense at it?
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:30, archived)
# I don't see your point.
That's why we carry on researching it. The fact that we struggle to make sense of observed data doesn't mean that we're equally entitled to believe any and everything else.

The situation with quantum stuff is that we have a puzzle. That's fine, interesting and good. What else do you want?
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:51, archived)
# My point was that Science shouldn't have a 'plausability' constraint on the theories it considers.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:54, archived)
# Eh?
Of course it should! A science that allows people to think the stark-raving bonkers isn't science.

It's sociology.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:56, archived)
# Quantum mechanics would be seriously held back if it could only consider things that seem plausible
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:06, archived)
# Only to a limited extent
Quantum theory attempts to reconcile certain implications of Einsteinian thought - which have been experimentally backed up - and certain observations. It's not quite as if it's generating claims ex nihilo
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:17, archived)
# The equations themselves have incredible agreement with the experiments,
far better than any other theories. But there's still a problem with how to interpret the experiments physically.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:22, archived)
# including the notion of a being that completely violates everything else we know
about the nature of reality

and takes extraordinary doublethink just to make is existence plausible?


see invisible pink unicorn, FSM, orbital teapot etc
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:48, archived)
# How would the existence of any kind of God violate any theories of Science?
I'm not saying God does exist, I'm just curious.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:50, archived)
# because to get complexity
- and a God would have to be the most complex being in the universe - requires a long, slow, gradual process of evolution

to say "he always existed and he is more powerful than anything else" means that he would have to violate everything we've learned about the nature of life
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:55, archived)
# So essentially, it would violate laws of entropy?
New evidence has constant been thrown at accepted theories and caused them to be altered, Science should always accept its current theories are fallible.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:59, archived)
# THIS^
is true
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:00, archived)
# but not just because people who have "faith" says it should
there's no reason to believe in God any more than there is to believe that Thor and his hammer causes thunder
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:01, archived)
# I can agree that there's not enough evidence at the moment for Science to seriously consider the existence of a God.
I can't agree with the instant dismissal of anyone who does happen to believe in a God.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:04, archived)
# I don't do that
and neither does Dawkins

but he very reasonably points out that blind faith is dangerous, divisive and illogical

which I agree with 100%
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:07, archived)
# I have heard it said by people before, often using Dawkins (probably incorrectly) to support them.
I admit, sometimes faith can get out of hand and lead to extremism, but that's only a tiny minority of people who believe.
I know many people who believe and for whatever reason, it helps them. So long as they're not hurting anyone, I don't see why it's such a problem for some atheists.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:11, archived)
# as I pointed out down there \/
Christopher Hitchens is probably the one this thread should be about


Dawkins gets a pretty unfair press because he's the one people know most about, and so is most easily lampooned
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:14, archived)
# Fair enough. I haven't read any of his stuff, just vaguely heard of him. Not good things.
I may be misdirected here due to Dawkins being used inappropriately against me in the past.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:17, archived)
# OK...
But it does accept fallibility. Meanwhile, the fallibility of scince doesn't mean that we have to consider the possibility of every other crackpot notion. There's a difference between "fallible in principle" and "foaming-at-the-mout-bouncing-off-the-walls-batshit-crazy"
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:03, archived)
# Nonsense!
Why would a god have to be the most complex being in the universe? It could be a pebble that just happened to be at the start of a causal chain that led to life, the universe and everything.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:02, archived)
# I can believe in a pebble
but it's stretching the definition of God as most people would accept it
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:09, archived)
# Exactly
If you take most of the classical arguments for God (in this case the cosmological) all that they can establish is that there is a God, and not that they are omnipotent, omniscient or should be worshipped or anything.

To be honest, whilst this discussion is endlessly interesting it is, I think, also endlessly pointless. The whole principle of faith dictates that you simply cannot know. There might be other discernible 'facts' that allow you to reach this conclusion, but whichever way you believe at least a good third of your belief will be unjustified. As such, both positions are to me equally tenable (though one far more attractive).
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:15, archived)
# I think...
The existence of a god wouldn't violate the principles of science, since science can always work with new data to adapt its understanding of the universe, but the way science has shown the world to reliably work makes the practicality of the existence of a god extremely unlikely.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:57, archived)
# Yep
It seems to me to be a mark of good science that we should believe in as few things as possible. If we can do without god to understand the world, we ought. And we can.
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:09, archived)
# ^ this
but if there was any evidence that God might exist, we wouldn't be having this debate

science can only deal with the evidence presented...since there is no evidence for a God then there's no reason to consider the possibility
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 16:12, archived)
# I can see this going off the end of the page
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:52, archived)
# o hai Geoff
(, Mon 17 Mar 2008, 15:59, archived)