Never read it, or even seen the film.I had a friend years ago who liked it and said it was good, but personally I can't say I like the whole demons and angels stuff. I prefer my to at least make no sense whatsoever, not cling to ancient mythology which makes no sense.
(,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:09,
archived)
It was good but not the best I've read under the same situation.Manga is perfect for when I'm at work as you can stop and start easier than a normal book. I'll have to grab some more tomorrow.
(
the_rhyme_minister has a little bit of gold and a pager,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:12,
archived)
Comics worth reading:Transmetropolitan,
V for Vendetta,
Top Ten,
Watchmen,
League of Extrodinary Gentlemen,
Marvel Zombies,
Tales from the Bully Pulpit,
There was another but I think I've forgotten it.
(,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:15,
archived)
V for Vendetta,
Top Ten,
Watchmen,
League of Extrodinary Gentlemen,
Marvel Zombies,
Tales from the Bully Pulpit,
There was another but I think I've forgotten it.
I think I'll have to read Watchmen.I've heard so much about it on here and now they're bringing a film out. If I read it before the film is released then I'll be able to pretend I'm an old die-hard fan and can act pretentious when people like it because of the film.
( the_rhyme_minister has a little bit of gold and a pager,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:17,
archived)
It's mentioned a lot as it was a comic which was annualised and made graphic novel annual collections more common, apart from having literature awards.Personally I think it is good, but not without its faults. There are elements in the writing, especially the book within a book in it which could have been laid out better and been easier to follow, or at least more subtly woven in. V for Vendetta in my opinion is far superior.
The film looks quite good, it looks gritty, cool, dark. However Watchmen wasn't really gritty or dark, you can just look at the contrast ratio on the trailer of the lights and darks, whereas the Watchmen comic was a sort of brownish saturated greyey colour as a lot of comics at the time were, which I think sort of added to the feeling of grim and seediness rather than hot kicking noir type stuff.
(,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:27,
archived)
The film looks quite good, it looks gritty, cool, dark. However Watchmen wasn't really gritty or dark, you can just look at the contrast ratio on the trailer of the lights and darks, whereas the Watchmen comic was a sort of brownish saturated greyey colour as a lot of comics at the time were, which I think sort of added to the feeling of grim and seediness rather than hot kicking noir type stuff.
Well you certainly know your shit.Just as I expected. I'll look into Watchmen and V for Vendetta. It's not like I have to pay for them anyway. Hopefully I'll get a quiet day tomorrow to read them.
( the_rhyme_minister has a little bit of gold and a pager,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:30,
archived)
Not really, I just have read a few comics, pretty much the ones I listed bar a few marvel and other ones which weren't very good.I just have a ridiculously high level of criticism FOR EVERYTHING!
I even managed to find faults with the writing in The Count of Monte Cristo for christ's sake.
(,
Tue 12 Aug 2008, 2:33,
archived)
I even managed to find faults with the writing in The Count of Monte Cristo for christ's sake.