is a misnomer that reveals the sexism of trans rights activists.
“Female” isn’t a presentation, it’s a neutral descriptor of sex.
So, I can guarantee that you can’t specify some aspects of “female presentation” without recourse to traditional notions of femininity, which aren’t actually anything to do with being female.
You’re referring to *femininity*, which is open to anyone who feels comfortable with it. It doesn’t make one female.
It’s truly bizarre that trans activists accuse their critics of conflating gender and sex, when it’s literally the case that that’s what their activism does as a foundation on which it’s all built.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 11:52, Reply)
Are we talking about traditional femininity? As in 'Women wear skirts and pretty blouses, men wear trousers' femininity? What can acceptably be perceived as 'feminine' or 'masculine' in the 21st century?
The whole neo Trans-rights movement is completely full of contradictions. There was a Reddit (unsurprisingly) thread a couple of days ago with a bunch of fuckwits complaining that UK media had been complicit in 'trans-erasure' because a number of outlets were referring to Brianna Ghey as female instead of 'trans-female'. And in the same breath condemning other outlets for using her birth name in the articles. The whole thing is a fucking mess, largely propelled it seems by clueless 'Allies' and adolescent fuckwits that aren't long past wanting to be an astronaut or a train driver.
If you have a penis, you should be obligated to use facilities intended for male members of society.
If you have a vagina, you should be obligated to use facilities intended for female members of society.
If you have been convicted of (or are currently under investigation for) sexual offences, legal or physical gender reassignment should be prohibited.
Treatment of gender dysphoria with puberty blockers should be outlawed as should any surgical procedures to address gender dysphoria before the age of 18 (I'd argue that 18 is still far too young to really know yourself, mind).
Besides that, I couldn't really give a fuck what gender somebody wants to be referred as or what kind of genitals they'd prefer to be equipped with.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 13:06, Reply)
Actually distinguish between sex and gender in law, and people can adopt whatever gender they want. It’s overwriting sex with gender that’s the issue.
And yeah, with Brianna, I’ve seen trans activists slagging off the parents for using “Brett”. It’s like, their kid started identifying as trans a few months ago, but those activists can’t actually grasp that maybe it’s OK for the, to mourn their son, and not to wholeheartedly accept that their kid’s gender issues defined him
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 13:15, Reply)
Who won’t actually admit that they know Eddie Izzard is male.
Can you imagine the cognitive dissonance in maintaining moral certainty that you’re in the right, even as you know for a fact you’re denying/ avoiding reality?
The ones who are really invested in their moral certainty won’t even say “look, I know Eddie is actually male, but because I think his own feelings matter, I’ll pretend he’s female”, even though they know that that’s exactly their thought process.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 13:19, Reply)
If you couldn't give a fuck why do you want to control what other people do?
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 17:02, Reply)
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 17:28, Reply)
Why is it that you hold both these opinions:
1: a man with a penis can be regarded as a woman is he says he’s one - and anyone demanding he has surgery before he can be regarded as female is a bigot
2: children who experience gender dysphoria need to hormonally and surgically alter their bodies to resemble the opposite sex
and don’t recognise the inherent contradiction, as well as the high likelihood that the experience of a 40 year old bloke with a penis and a wig is unlikely to be the same phenomenon as a young gay child whose parents bully him out of playing with dolls?
Jesus Christ you sanctimonious pricks haven’t realised yet that the game is up and you can’t just call people transphobes and have the questions disappear. Everyone who isn’t wilfully blind gets that you’re fucking batshit.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 19:46, Reply)
You're the person using the word transphobe, not a word I have used.
You're the one going one and on about children and their genitals, nothing I have talked about.
As to the two opinions you claim I hold, could you point out where I stated either of those points.
I mean it's a lovely narrative you have fabricated in your head, a pre prepared frothing rant, one you probably roll out every time this topic triggers you and you get all red faced and hammer those keys because someone somewhere is doing something you have no understanding of, nothing to do with and has zero impact on you and the anime fuck pillow you call a girlfriend. You tiresome cunt.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 20:39, Reply)
Outline what it is that you think. As if you have anything novel to say that isn’t straight out of the playbook you disingenuous, facile twat.
Yeah, it’d be really out of leftfield for me to think you might have “transphobia” as something on your radar, isn’t it?
And, to make it absolutely crystal fucking clear, the reason some of us have a necessity to refer to genitals IS BECAUSE YOU WANT TO PRETEND SEX DOESNT EXIST, AND YOU WANT TO DOSE CHILDREN UP WITH PUBERTY BLOCKERS BEFORE THEY CAN HAVE A CIGARETTE.
And really, if you’re going to use “ooh angry are you?”, then yes, believe it or not people get angry when people push regressive, physically harmful idealogues onto children.
What an absolute fucking prick you are. Read the article Prufrock posted and then have a serious fucking look at your life.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 20:45, Reply)
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 22:02, Reply)
So long as they’re able to give informed consent.
What I do maintain is that because trans activism’s beliefs and demands are incoherent, sexist, self contradictory bullshit, and drives a civil rights movement that seeks to remove women’s rights to any single sex spaces, anyone with a brain should be telling them to go fuck themselves.
As I said before, you’re so certain that because you think your cause is progressive, you must be right, that you clearly haven’t ever scrutinised whether your position makes sense. You’ve just been kind to your idiot mates.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 19:28, Reply)
…accusing someone of “arguing semantics” might just be the funniest thing I’ve ever read on this board
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 19:31, Reply)