You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1602362 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post It's so personal to you... Your bitterness to others and immature insistence on being recognized as an intellectual detracts from whatever your oh so nuanced and opaque position actually is.
You'd be more convincing if you concentrated on explaining what your progressive opposition to progress actually is, and what outcomes you are looking for.

The reason people assume you are a bigot is because you behave like one, and never actually explain what your secret intellectual argument really is.
(, Thu 30 Mar 2023, 20:08, Reply)
This is a normal post No secret
Trans activism is demonstrably sexist.
I’d argue it’s on you to say why males in women’s spaces is inherently progressive.
(, Thu 30 Mar 2023, 21:55, Reply)
This is a normal post Yeah, see, this looks like bigotry cynically pretending to be progressive,
pretending to be concerned for women and misgendering trans people to get this predictable response.

Seems like a boring way to antagonise people to me, and I should know.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 1:51, Reply)
This is a normal post On what basis are you suggesting
That a “claim” to support women is false?

Do you believe that the women who object are also falsely concerned about their rights?

Yet again, you demonstrate that your starting point is “any criticism can only be bigotry”, and also that your conclusion should also be “any criticism is bigotry” and so you can only allow yourself to find bigotry in anyone’s motives. And if you can’t find it, it must be “veiled”

It’s incredibly lazy, it’s very boring, and it stands up to no scrutiny at all.

Ever heard the principle of arguing against the best interpretation of an opposing view? Try that. Argue against me “as if” I am simply misguided in my concern for impact on women’s rights, rather than by telling me that I’m faking it for reasons unknown.

Fool.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 8:54, Reply)
This is a normal post Who are you quoting?
You need to actually listen to what people say and respond in kind. Your unconvincing preset arguments and straw men, when added to your deliberately antagonistic mis-gendering language, only serves to reinforce the idea that you're a closed minded bigot.

This high and mighty act of yours is not convincing. You come across as a bitter, impotent little troll. I see no evidence that you're arguing in good faith at all.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 14:11, Reply)
This is a normal post You’re seeing no evidence
Because you’re not prepared to accept that there is a good faith argument against many of the demands and actions of trans activism.

The hypocrisy of you accusing me of “preset arguments” when you frame my neutral, factual relevant description of transwomen as male as an egregious act of “misgendering” is amazing, and kind of the point: in the absence of a compelling reason why a subset of male people get to make it taboo to notice their sex (and it’s relevance) on their say-so, even when their assertion seems based on regressive stereotypes, then I simply don’t recognise you as having any moral high ground.

You’ll understand this position if you simply consider your likely view on Rachel Dolezal; my suspicion is you don’t respect her stated identity, and that you are perfectly happy to “misrace” her as white despite her assertions otherwise. Presumably you’d also recognise that black people had a point if they took issue with a group of white people who identified as black, then framed themselves as the most vulnerable black people?

God, this is tedious. Because you really haven’t ever given any of it a moments thought, never actually listened to a single thing an evil TERF said. And guess what? As stated earlier, accusations of bigotry get an eye roll when you’re burping it up at someone who has wrestled with the issue, listened to people across the board, as well as having spent their entire working life supporting society’s most vulnerable.

When I call people out for bigotry, I tend to be able to articulate the belief they hold that I believe to be wrong, why it’s wrong, and the impact of that wrong belief. I wonder if you can do the same? I doubt it.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 16:09, Reply)
This is a normal post There you go again.
The arguments, opinions, attitudes and life experience you ascribe to me are simply false. You're inviting me to defend arguments you have made on my behalf.

The misgendering, the whataboutism, the straw men, it's all rather transparent and shambolic. This is not arguing in good faith. It's low level antagonism, unworthy of /talk, let alone /links.

I am fully prepared to accept that there are good faith arguments against what you so neutrally described as "the demands and actions of trans activism." I'm not sure how this directly relates to my statement: "You'd be more convincing if you concentrated on explaining what your progressive opposition to progress actually is, and what outcomes you are looking for."
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 17:58, Reply)
This is a normal post You waded in
Accusing me of bad faith and bigotry. You are in no position to complain about others making assumptions about your beliefs.

Your question contains the phrase “opposition to progress”, which demonstrates that you are characterising my position as in opposition to progress, rather than (as I maintain it is) as being more progressive than the sexist aspects of trans activism.

If you genuinely are not aware of what those arguments are, then feel free to engage respectfully and I’ll happily outline them for you
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 18:21, Reply)
This is a normal post There you go again,
claiming that you have some clever and convincing arguments, claiming that your opponent, who you also argue on behalf of, is unworthy of hearing them.

You need some self reflection time, m8.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 18:45, Reply)
This is a normal post “Some good arguments”
My central argument is that sex exists and sometimes matters more than an internal, self reported, undefinable identity.

My sub-argument is that when discussing the areas where sex matters, I reserve the right to refer to sex rather than gender identity - eg the fact that trans women are male is pertinent to why it’s legitimate to exclude them from the female category in elite sports.

That won’t be good enough for you though, no doubt. Even though you don’t have a single coherent counterpoint.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 19:03, Reply)
This is a normal post Who are you quoting?
So you think good arguments are:
Belittling the life experiences of trans people because ???
You reserve the right to use language that you know will antagonise because ???

You can't stick to the point, mate. One moment it's womens rights, then safe spaces, then activism, now sports, it's as if you conflate everything that offends you and you just dump it all into a box marked 'trans=bad.'

I wish you could just articulate what it is about your conservative views you think is progressive, and what outcomes you want.

I don't need to counter any arguments that you make on my behalf, and I don't need to counter points made that fail to address the actual arguments that I'm making. If you want to be taken seriously (which is obviously important to you), you should argue in good faith, not like this.
(, Fri 31 Mar 2023, 19:23, Reply)
This is a normal post Dearie me you’re thick
Yes, I take issue with trans activism. As trans activism is unreasonable on several fronts, there are several fronts in which I disagree with trans activism’s unreasonable demands.
Your refusal to actually see the substance of any disagreement is your problem.

“Belittling life experiences”. Jesus Christ. Male people are male. That sometimes matters. There’s no “experience” that makes that untrue.

You’re very, very boring.
(, Sat 1 Apr 2023, 8:07, Reply)
This is a normal post You seem upset.
I'm not surprised that you find me boring, because I stick to the point and refuse to engage with your bad faith tactics of distraction, straw men, whataboutery, etc.

I wish that you were capable of explaining what your progressive opposition to progress actually is, and what outcomes you are looking for, but it's obvious why you can't. Firstly, as your closed minded 2nd paragraph perfectly illustrates, it's because your opposition to progress is not progressive. Secondly, your mind is clearly fogged with these chaotic, disordered culture warrior twitter memes.

I genuinely hope that you can be encouraged to see past it and correct yourself. Stage 1 would be to admit to yourself that the reason you are called out for bigotry is because of the things you say and the way you act.

Good luck.
(, Sat 1 Apr 2023, 15:12, Reply)
This is a normal post What on Earth makes you think
That “male people are female if they so so”

is “progress”?

That’s your shaky starting point. If you think that me not accepting it = bigotry, then that’s exactly why your accusation is meaningless. You literally have given no examples of bigotry, just assumed it, and failed to actually engage when given examples of the substantive issues I have with trans activism, one of which being “males demanding to be included in female sporting categories”

You have nothing, and you’re a fool. Upset? Mate, there are trans activists who actually argue. That’s interesting. The reason you’re boring is because you don’t even know what the argument is.
(, Sun 2 Apr 2023, 11:57, Reply)
This is a normal post Who are you quoting?
Why are you telling me lies about what my arguments are?

Why can't you see when I give you examples of your bigotry, as I have been doing all along?

Why can't you express what your progressive opposition to progress actually is, and what outcomes you are looking for?

The answers are simple. You are not honest. You do not argue in good faith. It's super transparent to other people. You need to face reality, m8.
(, Sun 2 Apr 2023, 14:51, Reply)
This is a normal post Try attacking the arguments
not the person.
(, Sun 2 Apr 2023, 20:35, Reply)