paperspast.natlib.govt.nz/newspapers/ESD19150510.2.9.1
(, Tue 15 Aug 2023, 17:28, Reply)
Both he and the wrights had experimental planes before 1903. The americans have tried to narrow their definitions down over the years to exclude pearce. Pearce thought his didn't have control, and tends to count only those flights that came later, after both his and the wright brothers first flights, as powered flights. But he flew a powered plane on a sustained flight before them, and achieved much greater distances than the wright brothers.
The wright brothers "flight" used a ramp to get a glider already aloft into a headwind, before it's little engine took it the length of a backyard. they might have got the same effect pushing a glider off a roof. But the yanks have built all this fanfare around the wrights, just as they did Edison "inventing" the lightbulb, and so they can hardly acknowledge any precedents
"Researchers into Pearse's aeronautical work had located some 55 surviving witnesses by the 1980s. They assigning a principal category to each witness at that time: 20 had seen a flight or more, 9 had seen a plane on a hedge or in the workshop awaiting repairs, 2 had heard the plane in flight but did not see it, 7 had a second hand account of seeing flight, 10 knew of flights and 7 had seen or knew of the flying machine under construction. Some dateable events recalled as occurring about the time of the flights were: immediately after excessive flooding of the Opihi River on 23–24 March 1902; on 31 March, preceding April Fools' Day; within a year of the end of the Second Boer War and following the disbanding of the 9th Contingent, New Zealand Mounted Rifles, South Island Regiment, in New Zealand on 21 August 1902; about the time of Eugen Sandow's visit to Timaru, 26–29 December 1902; during Honora Crowley's last teaching year at Upper Waitohi School to September 1903; and before the Big Snow snowstorm from 11 July 1903. Following decades of research to establish dates, 31 March 1903 is noted by historians as the day when Pearse achieved some sort of witnessed flight"
QEDKIWI
(, Wed 16 Aug 2023, 4:21, Reply)
I don't count a bunch of old people's recollections from 80 years earlier as particularly reliable. You know as well as anyone that people's memories are fallible; they remember what they want to remember, especially if a legend had already built up around a local man having a world first.
I'm sure you could find way more than 50 people in Roswell who'll swear blind that they saw aliens in 1957.
(, Wed 16 Aug 2023, 6:56, Reply)
personally, I reckon there's a decent probability that he did, but it's no more than that. It's more that i saw a doco on it and unlike your roswell example, the kiwi witnesses didn't seem like they cared much either way, a bit like Pearse himself, which makes them a bit more reliable. And it depends how you define these things. What is controlled? is it flight if you take of from the top of a ramp or are catapulted, like the wright brothers early flights? There are other contenders apart from pearse and the wright brothers if you use a broader definition
(, Thu 17 Aug 2023, 0:37, Reply)