It seems the F-16s the dutch and danes are giving Ukraine are going to take months to deploy because they have to train the pilots to understand English first. From an IT point of view it means GD built a 70 million buck plane but decided not to spend a few grand giving the interface and HUD multilingual support.
I don't know, maybe it was deliberate so if it fell into commie hands they couldnt use it
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 2:02, Reply)
Almost forgotten that flick
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 5:13, Reply)
It's not an F35 so no touchscreen interfaces - we're talking switches, illuminating panels and indicators, and screens with bezel keys (think ATM buttons). In order to make a foreign-language version of the cockpit you'd have to replace every switch and panel.
Until five or so years ago there was precisely fuck-all chance of these ending up in the hands of Russian-speakers (indeed it was designed to fight against them), much less Ukrainian. No mileage therefore in designing the hardware to support that. Or translating all the other Flight Manuals, Procedures, Maintenance Manuals, Part Labels, Placards, Safety Labels, and a thousand other things on that plane and its support ecosystem.
Much cheaper, easier, quicker and safer (lower impact of mis-translation) to train the operators to read English.
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 13:56, Reply)
a quick google shows both the danes and the dutch's entire fleet of f-16s received MLUs during the 2000s with modern computer systems retrofitted during extensive conversions of most of the planes avionics, guidance and weaponry www.f-16.net/f-16_versions_article2.html Now it doesn't say if the upgrades supported multilanguage, but it certainly could have if they'd have had a mind to
one interesting thing, and I'm no boffin, is that there seems to be very little over flights by russians planes or even large drones. It's like AA systems are in the ascendency, and neither side wants to risk pissing away millions by getting them shot down. so instead its all relatively cheap iranian drones, and those russian planes that are being used are almost like artillery, sploodging their loads from well inside the safety of their borders. Maybe the danes are saying "well, if you want to use them in combat you're welcome too, because we probably never will the way warfare is going"
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 14:32, Reply)
Thought we were discussing the front-end, not the back-end though.
A quick look at a modern F-16C cockpit will show you what I mean regarding switches, panels, etc. And, yes I do realise that's a Belgian one not a Danish or Dutch one.
As for AA: It's well known that the Russians specialised in Air Defence. This should hardly be a surprise as every war fought by NATO-aligned countries in the last sixty years or more has relied on air superiority. The S300 and S400 systems employed by both sides have made airspace over Ukraine an absolute deathzone since the first week of the invasion. Which is why stories like this matter.
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 15:53, Reply)
Anyway, I’m no expert, there’s probably more to it, most likely the lack of Ukrainian speaking trainers as you said. But modularising the language interface would be one of the easiest things to do, it’s just words, so if they haven’t designed for that it’s probably deliberate
Interesting what you said about the AA. I just knew there’s been hardly any stories of Russian plane attacks, which is weird because they’ve got a lot of planes and Putin wouldn’t have qualms about using them
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 22:33, Reply)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_aircraft_losses_during_the_Russo-Ukrainian_War#Russian_aircraft_losses_2
There's been plenty (on both sides). Notably the recent losses tend towards the close air support systems like Su-25 or Ka-52 largely I suspect because the interceptors have largely been withdrawn from the region and the heavier bombers are able to launch missile strikes from safer distances.
(, Fri 25 Aug 2023, 14:07, Reply)
there does seem to be drop in frequency from the first two months, perhaps reflecting the shift on the ground to one of slower attrition
(, Fri 25 Aug 2023, 21:42, Reply)
youtu.be/-PCg-ba9tRI?si=0fGK57EVtJXyMrPV
(, Fri 25 Aug 2023, 14:17, Reply)
What the F-16 gives that they don't currently have, is a platform to launch NATO stand-off ground attack weapons like the AGM-154 glide bomb or AGM-158 cruise missile. The US probably wouldn't be supplying those, but don't be surprised if the Polish stockpiles of those weapons suddenly shrink.
You also get a very potent anti-ship capability in the Harpoon. They currently have land-based versions but they're limited in range. Putting them on an aircraft would allow them to hold much of the Black Sea at threat.
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 16:13, Reply)
Because it doesn’t sound like they need them for dogfights
(, Thu 24 Aug 2023, 22:44, Reply)