It's unlikely the push was the sole cause of it.
Heart attacks happen because of unhealthy diets, not enough exercise and undiagnosed conditions.
I'm saying he was going to have a heart attack anyway, just the assault may have accelerated it and therefore he wasn't killed. It was a tragic accident at worst.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 22:40, Reply)
Whether triggering a heart attack constitutes 'killing' in a philosophical sense is perhaps a question you could debate.
In a legal sense though, it certainly does, no debate needed.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 22:45, Reply)
Here's the stpory I;ve pieced together so far:
Ian Tomlinson was using a peaceful demonstration technique withthe Police, walking slowly and generaly trying to slow them down. (not going home from work as said in newspapers)
His passive tactics infuriated the Police and one lashed out in frustration (and very wrongly)
10 minutes later Ian Tomlinson has a heart attack, probably aggrevated from the physical assult earlier.
Police and ambulance try to help but get caught in an unrelated attack by the "demonstrators" (read "rioters using a peaceful demonstration as a cover to launch attacks on the Police")
The Policeman should not of reacted in the way he did and should be punished for taking his frustrations out on a member of the public. Not for killing him.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 22:56, Reply)
"Police and ambulance try to help but get caught in an unrelated attack by the "demonstrators" (read "rioters using a peaceful demonstration as a cover to launch attacks on the Police")"
The medical student who was attempting to take care of him until help arrived, but was moved on by the police so they could charge at the demonstrators would disagree with you about this.
I don't know where you're getting your information from, but it's simply incorrect.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 23:01, Reply)
I didn;t know about the stuedfnt medic.
The report that the police adn ambulence tried to treat him but were attacked by rocks was the 1st story about this mans death to reach the main papers. I thought it was partly true (obviously missing out the being knocked over and the student medic parts)
I'm stil ltrying to see the whole picture with this so thanks for enlightening me.
Not sure how to take the "Police were being attacked" vs "police attacked 1st" area as of yet.
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 2:11, Reply)
The fact the Police Officer was overly forceful isn't debatable. The 100s of e-mail/facebook/myspace notifications saying "Charge the Policeman for murder" the 5 petitions I've been met with in person for the same cause are.
I do not and will not believe this was anything more than an unfortunate accident and think anybody pushing for anything more needs to learn more about heart attacks and their causes.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 23:04, Reply)

Prevents against mind controlling waves and falling spy sattelites at the same time.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 23:27, Reply)
He was doing some quite bad stuff.
He also thought arguing with mods was a good idea. ¬_¬
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 23:36, Reply)
A heart attack can indeed occur simultaneously with a traumatic event, however most do not, usually occurring up to half an hour after any stressful event. He was most likely not going to have a heart attack right there and then, however being 'accidentally' twatted from the rear by a lunatic more than likely caused his death.
(, Wed 15 Apr 2009, 10:01, Reply)