Interesting to a degree, but lost in so much crap about free speech! I hate it when people think we are America and that the ability/opportunity to say whatever you want no matter how offensive to others is a human right!
As far as I am aware nowhere in Europe is given that opportunity which is why we can prosecute for inciting hatred. Interesting and valid points are lost to a stupid discussion about a perceived freedom , oh,...mutter mutter... sorry, rant cut short!
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 21:32, Reply)
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_10_of_the_European_Convention_on_Human_Rights
says nothing about not blaspheming. unless you interpret "the protection of health or morals, for the protection of the reputation or rights of others" in such a way that it includes God.
edit: and we've still got a blasphemy law on the books here in the Netherlands, too.
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 21:53, Reply)
This is the bit -'subject to certain restrictions that are "in accordance with law" and "necessary in a democratic society".' - that people always seem to forget. I don't have a problem with people blaspheming; it's just too much American influence in our lives that make people think their laws are ours that drives me mad, and applies just as much to the religious respecting the Agnostic and Atheist views as is does the other way around.
As an aside though, I love the way you can swear all you like in Holland but one 'God Verdomme' (spelling?) and you get all sorts of evil stares...
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 22:38, Reply)
anyway, yes I know. but the article does not in actual fact say that countries can make up any law restricting speech, it goes on:
"may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society, in the interests of national security, territorial integrity or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, for the protection of the reputation or rights of others, for preventing the disclosure of information received in confidence, or for maintaining the authority and impartiality of the judiciary."
It's all pretty vague, but I can't really see any reason in there that would allow an anti-blasphemy law (unless you'd count the morals bit). It also says nothing about not offending people.
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 22:48, Reply)
You've completely lost me there mate
25,000 euro fine for saying God is imaginary because it's a crime of hate? Fuck that
'Blasphemy' as a concept has to be about the most ugly concepts of 'apparent human deviance' ever touted by humans; with all it's warped reasoning, and still is around the world. Religion/supernatural-faith as a concept is still one of the primary pains of humanity, such as scum like the Taliban having a puritanical vision of how our minds should operate, and thus viewing those who chose not to share their faith as lesser human beings; all the while subjugating half the population (women) into a state of servitude, and declaring the rest of us who don't share their fantasies about some sky bloke, or exactly what some profit taught, who married some eight year old or something, fair game
Also, perhaps i'm agnostic, but view the ecosystem and natural world of this planet could only have been the 'intelligent design' of a sadistic cunt. The natural world is a twenty four seven slaughter house. Why in thirteen billion years would I offer any praise to the grand architect of this? The very concept of a god is a complete cunt
People have the right to say I think this may be a load of bollocks, which isn't a crime of hate to the slightest degree. There are quite a few of us who might actually see it the other way round, and are fed up with the religious sermons of morality from various religious people, divided communities along religious lines, wankers protesting loudly outside abortion clinics causing further distress (what next, protests outside hospitals by people opposed to stem-cell research, fertility treatment, or blood transfusions on religious grounds?), and religious nutters like Al-Qaeda murdering lots of people, and intellectually opposed to democracy and freedom of thought, or other religious expression
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 21:57, Reply)
What I mean is that rational arguments as to whether or not a God, religion race or whatever are not governed by the 'right' to free speech, but are subject to an understanding that our actions (in this case verbal) have an effect in other people.
I agree that this would be a ludicrous law to pass, but banging on about how it violates someones right to free speech is the wrong argument to make as that right doesn't exist in the first place.
Personally I think all religion at it's core is the same and arguably beneficial by providing a framework with which to base a society/community assuming your suspension of disbelief remains intact - it's peoples manipulation to their own ends that cause the issues, of which this rule would indeed be a prime example of.
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 22:31, Reply)
yes it does. it's usually limited, yes - even in the US - but it certainly does exist, at least in most civilized countries.
it's a right in exactly the same way that being allowed go about your life without being locked up by the government is a right - yes you can really be imprisoned for committing crimes, but that's not the point.
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 22:44, Reply)
but not being a scholar on American law, theirs goes further right? Hence the legal existence of the KKK etc, whereas ours is a 'limited' right, recognised but restricted by the law of the lands and society to a degree...
I was meaning 'right' as the apparent commonly held view of absolute right that people so often use in these arguments whilst often conveniently overlooking the restriction part; it seems to misdirect attention from the actual issue and provide sensationalists the ability to sell tabloids...
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 22:51, Reply)
Free speech is free speech, whether it's Nick Griffon spouting off his racist bollocks, some Muslim prat shouting at a government minister at some meeting, or the Iranian President denying the holocaust, or me saying I might believe in a supreme being, but think it's always been a bit of a cunt; where on earth do you draw the line? You can't
The vast majority of people weren't outraged enough by cartoon depictions of the profit Mohammed to do all the crazy stuff like in other countries; all that reaction simply made me hate faith at that magnitude even more. I remember when lots of Muslims were yelling loudly about the Satanic Verses; that attitude can go and fuck itself, it caused only anger at the doorstep of those who clearly can't handle it, people like that can go and fuck themselves. That I guess is what you mean by ..."are subject to an understanding that our actions (in this case verbal) have an effect in other people.".
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 22:56, Reply)
I just find these discussions very interesting. Have a pearoast to make up for it...
b3ta.com/links/338444
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 23:12, Reply)
But isn't drawing the line what makes our government/society ours? It's always going to be an area of contention and constantly should be - As linked in the conversation above, article 10 recognises there are (and arguably should be) certain restrictions on just how far we can push it.
As an interesting slant on the religion front -I seem to remember the question being raised in the Bible somewhere as to what happens to people that were never given the opportunity to hear about God; they get a 'get out of jail free' card as such, so logically, in order to 'save the world' the religious (or Christians at least) should remain silent....
I'm sure if that is wrong I'll get pulled up on it by someone..... :)
As for the attitude you talk about I would agree with you entirely; Though perhaps I would continue to argue that it is the individuals desire to serve their own cause under the guise of religion rather than the ideology of religion itself. Read a book called The Calendar -it's the history of the calendar (ronseal enough) but has some very good examples of how Roman Catholicism impacted society to our detriment, and also how religion even got muddled up with governments in the first place by being used as a vote swayer.
(, Tue 14 Jul 2009, 23:10, Reply)