I wore black jeans about half the time,
and had a black coat, and I was never that into following fashion. I think that's enough to make you a Goth in most people's eyes. Most of my tops were in all different colours, though. I've never owned a band t-shirt.
( Moon Girl Technologies horrendous beanbag, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 13:12, archived)

I used to get that too.
I did have a pair of black jeans and various band t-shirts, but never put in enough effort to be a goth.
( my other username is a porsche , posting shit pictures so you don't have to, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 13:15, archived)

I had a black leather coat
It was a lovely cut, it wasn't in the 'Goth' style, it looked a bit more like a business coat but I still had shaven-head oiks yelling "GOFFF" at me.

I only had Queen band shirts. And one of The Who's shirts. So not really 'Gothic'.
(theneet began to cut her hair and long for balls, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 13:18, archived)