It’s not to inform or discuss, it’s to give yourself an opportunity to air your bigotry.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 8:08, Reply)
That sex remains something we can’t help but perceive; in fact, it’s an inherent consequence of a civil rights movement based on the idea that one group can demand to identify into a group that they’re not part of. Their identity is like a feather floating on a breeze, and they’re reliant on you to keep blowing to keep it afloat. Some of us, understandably, note that that isn’t sustainable and that it’s much better to deal with the reality that men who feel more comfortable with their idea of femininity can live according to their needs, without it meaning that we have to lie that they’re women.
And he’s absolutely fucking spot on to ridicule the idea of prescribing puberty blockers to young gender non conforming kids.
By the way, your mates who you know to all be happy? Little heads up for you - the social pressure within the trans cult to stick to the party line and remain totally committed makes Scientology look like a WhatsApp group for semi-regular five a side kickabouts. The question to ask is not “how happy do these people seem?” but “what consequences might a member of this group face if they were to voice a concern that transition had been detrimental to their physical and mental well being?”
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 11:48, Reply)
I assume you're part of the trans community then.
You're speaking from a place of expertise.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 16:58, Reply)
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 17:29, Reply)
Do you understand how discussions work? If I ask a question in response to something someone posted, it doesn't require to in some way to be linked to the OP, or the article they posted.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 17:44, Reply)
Requires me to be part of the trans community? none of what I said is reliant on understanding anyone’s experiences. You gonna tell me which part is wrong? (no, you’re not, because you can’t)
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 19:25, Reply)
So you can tell everyone how the trans community acts inside that community, but have no knowledge of that community, are you some kind of fucking mind reader?
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 20:30, Reply)
You realise that it is possible to observe social dynamics in action, right? You asked if I’m a member of the trans community. Ae you suggesting that members of a community are the only people with the means to analyse the way that community functions?
Really?
This really is all you have, isn’t it? You’re absolutely pathetic.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 20:36, Reply)
I care because of the damage being done to young lives. You just see this as another way to screech "left wing good, right wing evil." Pathetic tribalism is all you've got. This isn't a political issue but a medical one.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 13:27, Reply)
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 19:50, Reply)
In fact, I normally either post videos of artwork or have sometimes taken issue with some of the people I’m agreeing with here.
And guess what the best counterargument to my points I’ve heard here is? It’s “you might want to look at who you’re agreeing with”.
So Prufrock gets his point and questions ignored because of his posting history, I get my points and questions ignored because despite my posting history I agree with someone with a posting history you don’t like.
It’s almost as if there’s not a good counter argument to the substantive issues raised. I’ve noticed that not one of the people who are vaguely aligned with trans activism has articulated a defence or a counterpoint to what’s raised in the original article.
Man, the cognitive dissonance when Mermaids is shut down is going to be quite a sight to see.
(, Tue 14 Feb 2023, 20:24, Reply)