to have ignored my post below and had this 24 hour argument instead.
We could all have gone down a fun Automata UK rabbit hole, and ended up having a classic Spectrum vs C64 scrap.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 16:38, Reply)
you donkey-raping geronto-necro-paedo-KFC-United-loving father-fucker!
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 20:19, Reply)
If you're judging based on C64 ports of Speccy games and vice versa, the original usually looks better. If you're judging based on arcade ports, the C64 usually looks better (I say usually, but I can't think of an exception). I'm occasionally still amazed by C64 demos. If you're judging based purely on vectors, maybe the Speccy wins. If you're judging on literally anything else to do with graphics, resolution, frame rate, scrolling, sprites, colours, etc., the C64 wins.
There's a stylistic uniformity to Speccy games. I can understand the nostalgia for it, but I never thought it looked good at the time.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 23:29, Reply)
The C64 wasn't as pixelly, and not as brightly coloured. It looked better at the time for the reasons you mention, but now looks quite bland - you still get indie games looking like that. The Spectrum's limitations and quirks means it takes you straight back to the 80s.
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 0:11, Reply)
most of the spectrum games were ported to c64, but less the other way. And they just looked better on the commodore. the vic 20 was an abomination, though.
a few years ago when I went on a nostalgic look back, they had dated and I preferred the DOS version, something I never saw at the time because no one had an early ibm in my suburb
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 23:40, Reply)