You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1606529 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post Lots of bad understanding of jargon in that article,
which is odd, considering the name of the publication and its intended readership. Robert Zubrin would be pulling his last remaining hair out if he read this.

All of these 'scifi engine cuts journey time to Mars" stories are daft. A Hohmann transfer is the most efficient way to travel from one body to another, it will always have a specific delta-V requirement and will always take as long as it happens to take. You could do a less efficient burn to reduce transit time using current technology, or with a super special scifi engine that doesn't exist yet. The inefficiency of the faster transit time remains even with an imaginary fusion drive, or even with a magic reactionless drive.
(, Wed 12 Jul 2023, 14:49, Reply)
This is a normal post
But this is claiming to be that super special scifi engine, so you won't have to worry about Hohmann transfers and all that. It would put us one step closer to a torch drive.
(, Wed 12 Jul 2023, 15:19, Reply)
This is a normal post Which is still a massively inefficient way to spend resources and energy.*
*Assuming time is not a critical factor.

Whatever, we don't need to wait for this scifi fusion technology to send people to the planets. Fission rockets are already a thing, but we don't even need them either.
(, Wed 12 Jul 2023, 16:11, Reply)
This is a normal post
The article and the video didn't mention efficiency at all. They emphasised speed.
(, Wed 12 Jul 2023, 18:32, Reply)
This is a normal post Yeah, 500,000mph.
A very meaningful and useful number when discussing rocket engine capability.

My point is that these stories about scifi engines promising to cut journey times are bollocks, as demonstrated by the confused and, dare I say, deliberate misuse of jargon.

The 'Made In Chelsea alumnus' Richard Dinan mentions "exhaust speeds" but says nothing about delta-v, ISP, or TWR, or about the mass of the engine itself, or about the energy demands it might have in terms of ignition, et-bleedin'-cetera. He also pronounces nuclear "new queue lear" which is just enraging.

The video actually suggests we will need their precious Star Trek technology to leave Earth orbit. They are simply preying on the ignorant and the gullible.
(, Wed 12 Jul 2023, 19:58, Reply)
This is a normal post Well it would be a bit silly to prey on those who weren't gullible.
Selling dreams is a big market.
(, Wed 12 Jul 2023, 20:14, Reply)
This is a normal post "Delicate finessing of delta-V is sign you haven’t really got enough power."
Banks really was a master of the incisive jab.
(, Fri 14 Jul 2023, 8:56, Reply)