And quantum woo allows for atheistic dualism. Backing down would be an admission that people aren't special, which is unacceptable.
A pity really. A lot of his mathematical work is outstanding, and he's still productive which is unusual given his age.
(, Tue 31 Oct 2023, 16:13, Reply)
as you call it, is the same as is successfully used in quantum computers. They are able to perform calculations impossible (not just difficult) for classical computers. This is the difference he claims makes it impossible for an AI resulting from classical computation to achieve consciousness.
In short, the set of BQP problems is larger than the set of PH problems.
It's a completely different discussion whether consciousness is fully contained within the set of PH problems, or whether is it wholly or partly only in BQP. Penrose asserts that it is only possible using quantum calculation, although to my mind this raises the possibility of a quantum computer becoming conscious. What it isn't, though, is just handwaving and asserting that people are special out of some superiority thing.
(, Wed 1 Nov 2023, 9:25, Reply)
His argument basically boils down to: there are microtubules in the brain which could be doing something at the quantum scale, so we are not simply deterministic machines, all hail human exceptionality.
(, Wed 1 Nov 2023, 9:43, Reply)
he states in there that he now has a better understanding of what's going on than when he wrote that, at least on the quantum level.
He also says, multiple times, that he's not a biologist. He's just explaining how in physics the unexplained portion of the calculation required for consciousness at the speed we exhibit can be explained, and if that's the reality of what's going on then that precludes AI becoming conscious, at least with classical computers.
One of the great things about science, though, is if you have a better thought out alternative explanation you can write a paper about it and that becomes the prevailing status quo...
(, Wed 1 Nov 2023, 14:00, Reply)
(I haven’t watched the video. He’s certainly had plenty of time to improve his theory, and of course he’s a vastly better mathematician than I ever had any hope of becoming.)
(, Wed 1 Nov 2023, 21:01, Reply)
If you have any interest in the topic, to my mind it's one of the better ideas for what's actually going on down at the bottom level of reality. I had this idea a few years ago, and I've been waiting for someone (like you say, someone who does the maths a lot better than me) to propose it in the science community.
There isn't any maths in the video.
He's right that it's gravity that collapses the wave function, but he has yet to take the logical step and incorporate black hole universe generation, which says that forward in time is 'inward' towards the singularity, so if superpositions ignore time, then they also ignore gravity (being that they are the same thing as implied in General Relativity) and so the collapse of the wave function is simply the particles interacting with something too large to ignore time/gravity and the particle is then dragged along towards the singularity, that being forwards in time.
(, Thu 2 Nov 2023, 9:16, Reply)
It's quantum woo.
I agree that efficiently solving problems in bqp would be a fine thing though. I hope someone manages to fabricate qubits good enough for error correction soon.
(, Wed 1 Nov 2023, 12:56, Reply)