It's the way it compresses your chest. Some people just drink out the far side really quickly and go "well, that didn't help". But it works for my everytime when I do it slowly.
(, Tue 6 Jan 2009, 13:10, Reply)
The water goes down in the same way and doesn't really touch the diaphragm. Surely, if you're going to try it at all, it makes better sense to take water into your mouth, THEN stand in whatever strange position you want to and swallow it?
(, Tue 6 Jan 2009, 13:16, Reply)
I think it's as much about the concentration as it is the technique, I don't understand people's venom towards differing ones, as long as it works for you then where's the issue?
(, Tue 6 Jan 2009, 13:21, Reply)
I just think it's mostly psychological. I don't stand on my head and drink warm milk with white pepper when I get a nervous twitch in one of my fingers, toes, or a thigh muscle, etc. I just move which ever muscle is causing the problem and it stops.
You can't easily do that with your diaphragm though, and people mistakenly believe that risking choking yourself solves the problem when you force peristalsis to work against gravity. It's mental.
(, Tue 6 Jan 2009, 13:25, Reply)