but we are seeing a short clip that doesn't show what happened before. He could have been fucking about for ages for all we know. People don't generally push people over for nothing, even nasty policemen.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:13, Reply)
That's a bit like saying that it was OK to sink the Belgrano because there was a warzone somewhere behind it.
I'm not saying he was pushed over for nothing. I'm saying that the evidence is that he was pushed over for apparently nothing. Was there any need at that time for the policeman to act as he did? Nope. Was there any justification? None that any of us can see.
So, absent anything else, we have to go with what the video says.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:23, Reply)
Context is everything in a case like this, that video has none
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:37, Reply)
We see a man walking calmly away from police with his hands in his pockets.
What would you count as context? Even if he'd just been hurling abuse at them, it wouldn't warrant the kind of treatment meted out, which was far more than was reasonable for self-defence or his lawful apprehension (noting, of course, that the need was not felt to apprehend him anyway).
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:43, Reply)
What I meant was the context the video was shot in. E.g. what was he doing/how was he acting before the video started, what were the police doing, did he have friends with him etc. etc.
I'm not taking sides in the argument, I'm just saying that basing everything on the above video is a bit premature and dangerous.
Not having a go at anyone mind! Don't want to cause another argument :os
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:17, Reply)
I like argument!
My point is that, since all we have to go on is the vid, and there's neither anything in the vid to suggest much in the way of prior aggravation, nor any suggestion that he was arrested after, then it's reasonable to suppose that the vid is a tolerable guide to the context.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:23, Reply)