You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 301118 | Random

This is a link post G20 Meltdown - Death of Ian Tomlinson
Recently released video showing the police attack during the G20 Meltdown protest at the Bank of England, London, 1st April 2009, which led to the tragic death of Millwall fan Ian Tomlinson
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 9:07, Reply)
This is a normal post Thugs.
Give them a crash helmet a uniform and a big stick and they're still a dirty thug.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 9:14, Reply)
This is a normal post was posted yesterday
horrific outcome :(
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 9:24, Reply)
This is a normal post Tragic Accident
Is there any evidence linking the unnecessary heavy handed police officer with his death?

Saying he was in the wrong place at the wrong time would be flippant. Personally I'd have steered well clear of Threadneedle St.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 9:37, Reply)
This is a normal post Evidence?
Well, that's one of the things at which the investigation'll look. You're right: it's possible that his time was limited anyway. But it's also indisputably the case that the shove and his death were close together, so it's not unreasonable to ask the question.

Either way, the unwillingness of the police to help a clearly dazed man up, combined with their frank mendacity after the event, doesn't look all that good...
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:18, Reply)
This is a normal post I wouldn't support the Police in this but...
... it was a heart attack, he was going to have it anyway, he just happened to be there. Now if it had been a brain injury...
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:15, Reply)
This is a normal post
I wonder whether his chest struck the ground when he fell. Death was clearly not soon enough after the fall to be be "commotio cordis", but I wonder whether there might have been "contusio cordis" or "Myocardial Stunning Due to Sudden Emotional Stress" content.nejm.org/cgi/content/abstract/352/6/539.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:17, Reply)
This is a normal post He should of moved away.
instead of walking right in front of the police line.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:20, Reply)
This is a normal post Why?
You're getting close to saying that it was the police who were the innocent bystanders here.
"Sarge! He's got his hands in his pockets! He might be a terrorist!"
"Fackin' 'ell. Get 'im, lads!"
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:23, Reply)
This is a normal post ??
He should have moved away or what he dies?

Are you saying he deserved to die simply because he wanted to go home?
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:26, Reply)
This is a normal post looks to me....
like he was purposely staggering left and right in front of them to slow them down/piss them off. Not condoning it but I don't see the strike with the baton nor does he react to supposed strike so as far as I can tell he was dicking about in front of them, one pushed him over and unfortunately he had a heart attack and died later. Its not exactly a Rodney King moment.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:32, Reply)
This is a normal post Allow, for the moment, that he was playing silly buggers.
I still don't see how that mitigates the assault.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 10:51, Reply)
This is a normal post in a situation where there's already been violence?
anyone with a shred of common sense who had *nothing* to do with the riot, as is being claimed, would've got out of there sharpish. The police, already on edge, went too far, but it's not like they beat the guy to death. It was his heart that gave out, probably because of his lifestyle, not because he was pushed over. How many people do we know who've had heart attacks brought on from being pushed over? If everyone who was pushed over died, I'd be a dirty, no-good, serial killer.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:05, Reply)
This is a normal post Um...
OK - so what's the officially-approved timelapse? See, my understanding is that the violence - which was fairly minimal anyway - had dissipated by mid-afternoon; this was in the evening. The fact that there'd been trouble several hours before doesn't strike me as important here. (My facts may be wrong, of course - do correct me.)

No, they didn't beat him to death. But there was still an assault, and it's possible that that was a contributory factor in his death. That's for the post-mortem and the coroner's court to decide.

I'm impressed that you're able to give such a comprehensive medical assessment based on video shot on a phone. Really.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:20, Reply)
This is a normal post Well...
I am appearing on CSI this week.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 13:17, Reply)
This is a normal post I'm not saying it mitigates anything
but we are seeing a short clip that doesn't show what happened before. He could have been fucking about for ages for all we know. People don't generally push people over for nothing, even nasty policemen.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:13, Reply)
This is a normal post ...
That's a bit like saying that it was OK to sink the Belgrano because there was a warzone somewhere behind it.

I'm not saying he was pushed over for nothing. I'm saying that the evidence is that he was pushed over for apparently nothing. Was there any need at that time for the policeman to act as he did? Nope. Was there any justification? None that any of us can see.

So, absent anything else, we have to go with what the video says.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:23, Reply)
This is a normal post Context
Context is everything in a case like this, that video has none
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:37, Reply)
This is a normal post I'm not sure that there's none...
We see a man walking calmly away from police with his hands in his pockets.

What would you count as context? Even if he'd just been hurling abuse at them, it wouldn't warrant the kind of treatment meted out, which was far more than was reasonable for self-defence or his lawful apprehension (noting, of course, that the need was not felt to apprehend him anyway).
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:43, Reply)
This is a normal post Sorry
What I meant was the context the video was shot in. E.g. what was he doing/how was he acting before the video started, what were the police doing, did he have friends with him etc. etc.

I'm not taking sides in the argument, I'm just saying that basing everything on the above video is a bit premature and dangerous.

Not having a go at anyone mind! Don't want to cause another argument :os
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:17, Reply)
This is a normal post Awwwww...
I like argument!

My point is that, since all we have to go on is the vid, and there's neither anything in the vid to suggest much in the way of prior aggravation, nor any suggestion that he was arrested after, then it's reasonable to suppose that the vid is a tolerable guide to the context.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:23, Reply)
This is a normal post on the other hand, from the video
his actions could be seen as hoping for the police line to pass him by and leave him alone. He was being non-threatening, head down, no eye contact, hands in pockets and no sudden movements.

He was also quite likely unaware that the police tactics for the day were to keep people in a contained area, so would not have known that there was little chance that they'd just walk by him. And instead of talking to him with a simple "move along" which may have worked, or even prior warning that he was going to be attacked (he doesn't have a chance to turn around, or take his hands out of his pockets) he was assaulted. It's either simple bullying by the officer in question, or really shit policing if that's now acceptable.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:07, Reply)
This is a normal post It is also said...
.. that the heart attack may have already been well in on the way, and his appearance of being sluggish and slow was due to him being rather unwell before he was pushed. Heart attacks aren't always wallop, they are often preceeded by not feeling well.

So.. his actions may have been totally missread, and therefore the question is whether the police acted fairly according to what they perceived to be happening. In my eyes, they didn't, but that's just my opinion.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 11:36, Reply)
This is a normal post I usually try to stay out of these things but..
-If a heart attack was on the way, it was going to happen anyway.
- The push does seem a bit overly forceful but on a day when there was rioting I think you'd be a bit jumpy to?
- He does seem to be staggering a little and weaving in front of the police, as though he's drunk.
- The heart attack happened 10 minutes later, not 2 or 3 but 10. Easy enough recovery time from a fall.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:05, Reply)
This is a normal post ...
But don't you think that jumpiness is one of the last qualities we'd want in a policeman?

The heart attack could well be a red herring. It still looks like an assault to me.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:11, Reply)
This is a normal post yes its an assault
but its hardly a beating, my mother has worse in mosh pits and she's older. Until I see more video or better video or at least video with sound I'm not going to judge it as any worse than someone being pushed over, a sight I see almost weekly in the town I live in.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:25, Reply)
This is a normal post Assault is assault.
It's any non-consensual touching.

A most pit probably counts as implicit consent.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 12:30, Reply)
This is a normal post Thats just the other extreme
I didn't consent to the guy touching me on the train this morning, its hardly something to cry assault about, OK this was obviously assault but assault has many degrees and only a fool would consider any non-consensual touching to be assault.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 13:09, Reply)
This is a normal post Well, it's the legal definition...
Except with the addition of "deliberate", which I forgot.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 13:54, Reply)
This is a normal post ok,
1. Not true at all, stress can bring a heart attack on, this is some pretty basic stuff.
2. There wasn't really any rioting, one broken window isn't a riot.
3. No, he just doesn't.
4. Contradicting point 1, but anyway it's not, check your facts.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 15:33, Reply)