You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 326025 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post This assumes the virtue of electoral democracy.
I'm not convinced. It makes too many assumptions about the disinterestedness, rationality, education and insight - the practical wisdom, if you will - of the electors.

Nor do I see why the mere fact that a policy is popular lends any weight to its being desirable. It's possible to have a majority desiring something abhorrent, and, that being the case, I'm not sure that there'd be any virtue in giving it to them.

No, I don't have any worked out alternatives. But in a world as complex as the one in which we live, I just don't buy the idea that mere popularity is all that good a way of forming policy decisions.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:54, Reply)
This is a normal post Your last sentence
says it all. No; our system isn't perfect, but no-one has come up with anything better that I'm aware of.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:03, Reply)
This is a normal post It's hardly a ringing endorsement.
For what it's worth, I'm all for revisiting and bastardising elements of Rousseau and Kant, with a bit of Plato and Aristotle thrown in.

That seems like a start.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:09, Reply)
This is a normal post Exactly
Its FAR from perfect (because its an imperfect world), but its better than pretty much any other form of government. Democracy ISN'T mob rule, because it works within a framework of laws. Parties break those laws, and they should, and hopefully will be brought up for it.

I realise I'm horribly optimistic about all of this, but you have to have some ideals, even when the reality of them sorta sucks.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:14, Reply)
This is a normal post And those laws come from where?
If a law is good because it's popular, then the moment it stops being popular it's no longer a good law - and so it's always at the tender mercy of opinion, however strange or undesirable that opinion might be.

If it's good because of some other factor, then why appeal to its popularity at all?

It's like a political version of the Euthyphro dilemma.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:17, Reply)
This is a normal post Well I'm not too proud
to say I am not familiar with you last sentence. But get on with your work! You can tell me another time.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:22, Reply)
This is a normal post Euthyphro, mate of Plato
Is the team selection right, which is why Clough selected it? Or is it right because it was selected by Clough?
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:35, Reply)
This is a normal post Oh, I think I know the one
although philophosy isn't my strong suit. (I'm quite good at bullshit though). I'm more into psycology to explain the human condition: Maslov, Van Voight, Jerry Springer, Ant and Dec.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:48, Reply)
This is a normal post oh stop wheeling out this crap,
it makes you sound like a sixth former who wears DM boots.

You wrote this all over my Facebook profile with a bunch of stuff about how you'd rip up your ballot paper, and how the voters' views were worthless, and then at the same time you wrote "fears the BNP will get in" as your status and prompted people to sign an online petition.

Hello, this is the real world and practicality is a useful way to survive it.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 17:02, Reply)