but when you read a story like this: www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/politics/G20/article6020028.ece (which obviously has a massive slant on it) you can maybe see why they would need to defend themselves
EDIT: I'm sure I'll probably get loads of abuse for posting this. I don't have an agenda though.
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 19:40, Reply)
I think I'll get the worst of it. I have no agenda either!
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 19:47, Reply)
www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/apr/07/video-g20-police-assault
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 19:51, Reply)
I have already read that article and seen that footage over and over again, and it appears what that officer did was unforgiveable.
He has now come forward though and I think he has been suspended? I might be wrong.
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 19:56, Reply)
and it was discussed at length on here, although i didn't join in.
There is also later footage of the Police and paramedics having things thrown at them as they tried to treat him. It is very hard to be objective about the whole thing. The policeman who assaulted this man will, I hope, lose his job, as I doubt he is fit for the role.
But was that his plan that day? Unlikely.
What was 'ninja' guys' plan that day? Peace?
why the masks guys? Are they all with the Goat and worry they will get chipped for having an opinion?
Or just hell bent on trouble...
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 20:07, Reply)
one of their reporters managed to join up with one of the groups and follow them around.
Basicly the peaceful protests were used as cover by "Anarchists" who seemed to care more about fighting the Police than with having any solid political plan.
It;s a problem you get with most demonstrations.
You need to try and understand that the Police can find it quite hard to determine between those demonstrating peacefully and those there for a barney until it kicks off. This means that some tiems they are reacting to a percieved threat when non exists, sometimes to a threat that does exist and sometimes just reacting in frustration.
Don;t think I'm defending the Police and some of their actions, I'I'm not. I just think that you need to try and see things from the other sides point of view to begin to really udnerstand what happened.
Back to topic. I believe the Police involved lashed out due to other frustrations and the man was the unfortunet scapegoat. They still should be punished for this as it is unforgivable even when you start to understand why. I think Police to need to study demonstrations and to see where the violence comes from and try to identify the signs that preludes violence so that they can react quicker and towards the correct parties involved.
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 20:59, Reply)
a common tactic for "passive protestors"
If he was genuinely an innocent bystander he would have waited for the police to pass by or walked at a normal pace (faster than the police were walking)
If you've got heart problems then dont get involved with demonstrations!
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 21:11, Reply)
I hadn;t thought of that. Another view point to take into consideration but I still think the reaction was a bit over the top.
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 22:17, Reply)
But at the same time, it must be noted that the headlines never read "Bored Police turn up en masse in London looking for a fight". Because they don't on the whole.
They might well read, but rarely do: "Anti-rich people thugs, trying to hide who they are despite claiming they have the moral high ground, turn up illegaly and do illegal things like smash things up in order to protest at thier perception of a government or institution acting illegaly. When provoked, the Police kicked thier heads in"
I'd be a shit headline writer.
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 19:45, Reply)
Well put. But you're right about staying away from headlines :)
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 19:47, Reply)
It's got just the right blend of distortion and irony-blindness.
As is de rigeur, it completely ignores repeated assertions by senior police officers prior to kick off, as it were, that they were "up for it".
The glib presumptions that it's OK for the police to kick people's heads in and that the people being kicked must have done something to deserve it are right there in the Associated Newspapers style guide.
And the reference to "trying to hide who they are" is a satirist's dream: just what have these people got to hide?
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 22:11, Reply)
I think you missed my point. I doubt any senior police officer said they were 'up for it' that sounds a Socialist Worker headline.
But ok, let's pretend they did. Up for what?
"Up For" they suspected Rent-a-mob was going to cause trouble?
Good.
"Up For" stopping our government and those of other countries being bombed, attacked, sniped or just bullied into an action that isn't appropriate?
Good.
"Up for" stopping people mindlessly smashing windows and boasting down the pub that they are Eco freedom fighters?
Good.
I hope they are Up For every one of them.
(, Mon 13 Apr 2009, 23:17, Reply)
My Dad died, in a Hospice. But the Hospice did not kill him. Sometimes where you are is not proof of murder.
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 0:47, Reply)
 
(, Tue 14 Apr 2009, 15:37, Reply)