Don't know NYC that well
But there is a bar in Houston called the "Hobbit Cafe" which has this many different beers, but, yes, still over 21.
( fagilliD Fuck I'm good!, Sat 11 Jun 2011, 9:15, archived)

I've seen blackthorne cider, but never tried it.
unfortunately I'm not one for beers :( I like to have cider, krupnik, cocktails (though those are shit for getting pissed on, unless I make them myself), gin and tonic and straight rum, and some ages Tequilas. I prefer most of my alcohol pure, I like to see whether they can stand up on their own.

If I'm just getting pissed I'll buy a cheap bottle of famous grouse and mix it with some thing though, haha. Once I just downed about 20cl or whatnot. That was a good evening.
( Rev. Cleo still alive, Sat 11 Jun 2011, 9:53, archived)