You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1605647 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post No, you miss the point
The point is that for a LOT of straight men with some casually sexist behaviours and attitudes, “treating someone as a woman” asks literally nothing of them. So a good barometer as to whether they are willing to do something that demonstrates *meaningfully* seeing a male who claims to be a woman as being a woman, is whether they would include trans women, people with penises, in their dating pool. If not, the it’s a bit rich to demonise women for maintaining that “sex matters”, since they have a sex based criteria for dating which “identity” won’t overwrite or override.

You’re confusing a “necessary condition” with a “sufficient condition” when talking about not wanting to have sex with “most biological women”; because sex matters to you in your sexual orientation, “being female” is a necessary criteria for a straight male to experience sexual attraction, but isn’t in itself enough.

Perhaps if you accept that, you can see why many same sex attracted women object to getting flooded with messages from balding blokes in lipstick maintaining that they are lesbians and that not considering them as potential sexual partners is transphobic?
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 13:10, Reply)
This is a normal post Perhaps people
who'd call someone a bigot for not wanting to have sex with them *and* people who'd define a woman as someone they'd have sex with are both awful cunts?
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 13:33, Reply)
This is a normal post Yep. I agree
Fortunately, that’s not remotely what I was doing; recognising that “I see trans women as women” is something men can *say* without having to consider any practical implications, but is something that actually has a tangible impact on women, does not equate to “defining a woman as someone I’d have sex with”
What I am doing, is coming up with an example where

1: sex matters to straight men,
And
2: seeing male people as female actually asks something of straight men

and noting that in the example, suddenly every “progressive” straight man demonising women for wanting single sex spaces actually has their own single sex space reserved for female people, where male people are excluded, however they identify.

Again, learn the difference between “necessary” and “sufficient”

Just because you’ve only ever seen twats like Owen Jones summarise a straw man version of the feminist critique of trans bullshit doesn’t mean that you understand the first thing about it x
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 13:56, Reply)
This is a normal post Where do trans men fit into your weirdly genital-obsessed bigotry apology?

(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 14:32, Reply)
This is a normal post “Weirdly genital obsessed”
Using an example of where sex matters to straight men is not “genitally obsessed”. We can accurately perceive sex at a glance in 99.99% of cases.

Do you have a specific question about trans men? Do you think that a feminist critique of trans activism doesn’t recognise that, being female, trans men also experience sexism from male people and from a society structured around privileging males?

If you’re talking about something as trite as “what bathroom do they go in” galaxy brain crap, then my answer, based on actually understanding the issues from various perspectives is simply this: in situations where sex matters, trans men’s sex, is obviously relevant.

Great gotcha there!
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 14:50, Reply)
This is a normal post You took umbrage at 'weirdly genital obsessed' (despite being the person who brought genitals into the conversation again)
but apparently you're fine with your argument being described as an apology for bigotry.

It's all a bit toryboy isn't it? All this wanging about, defending bigotry against trans people, using the same tired genital-based and sexually obsessive arguments bigots used against against giving rights to gay people back in the day.

The delusions of grandeur are just the cherry on top.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 15:05, Reply)
This is a normal post Would you prefer me to be like
“oh god please don’t call me a bigot”? I don’t give the first fuck what you call me, because I know the subject inside out and know exactly what I think, why I think it, and what it’d take to change my mind.

You on the other hand, are here somehow confused that “genitals” might be relevant to a conversation or a debate about whether members of one sex should have the right to legally be recognised as being the opposite sex.

You’re about six years out of date on this, I’m afraid. But very, very well done on “being kind”
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 15:11, Reply)
This is a normal post You're not upset by the accusations of delusions of grandeur either.
It must be that thick skin of yours.

Did I call you a bigot?

Why do you think I'm confused? Your use of English isn't great, but I can follow it easily enough.

Why do you want to distract from your expert argument by descending into personal insults? Aren't you above this level of discourse, what with you being ever so intelligent?
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 15:21, Reply)
This is a normal post If you think I’m trying to distract from my argument
Then by all means feel free to point out any logical flaw whatsoever with anything I’ve posted here.

Or you could just say “what about trans men?” and “it’s just like gay rights” without ever having thought for a minute about the actual impact of trans activism on young women with dysphoria, or ever wondered whether there are any substantive differences between trans activism and the gay rights movement.

It’s boring to the point of tedium, so say something interesting or don’t bother,
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 15:29, Reply)
This is a normal post So you have a bit of a thing for Paris Lees, got it.

(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 16:23, Reply)
This is a normal post I just wish I could say something interesting.
Oh well, that told me. I must be wrong if I'm boring the dynamic and invigoratingly intellectual clinteastwoodbradfield.

I'm sure he's not a concern troll, despite all evidence in support of that assertion. I'm sure he's right to stick up for the rights of biological women to express their presumably justified fear and hatred of icky weirdo trans women, all of whom are potential paedophiles, rapists, animal abusers, and GOD knows what else.

God I wish I had half his brains.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 17:42, Reply)
This is a normal post Yeah, but paris lees y/n/o

(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 17:52, Reply)
This is a normal post You just made me look up someone who played themselves on Hollyoaks
and I suspect that fact will live with me forever. Thanks.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 19:06, Reply)
This is a normal post Stop skirting the issue.
Yes, no, or once?
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 19:18, Reply)
This is a normal post Even if I would, she probably wouldn't.
But I'd say O with an option for Y, but given her history I'd have to see proof that she's clap-free first.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 21:52, Reply)
This is a normal post Recognising that trans women are male
does not = hatred.
(, Wed 21 Jun 2023, 11:09, Reply)
This is a normal post Odd that you should bring that up in its own post,
considering that nobody challenged you on your bigoted misgendering this time.

You really are a weirdo, and I should know.
(, Wed 21 Jun 2023, 14:07, Reply)
This is a normal post Well, I don't watch Owen Jones videos,
so your last paragraph is straw man Inception.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 15:31, Reply)
This is a normal post Phew, good robust engagement
See you next time the topic comes up, where you’ll make exactly the same incorrect assumptions without actually understanding the first thing about the clash of rights which is the actual substance of the trans debate.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 15:33, Reply)
This is a normal post All I said was that it's not bigoted to reject anyone sexually,
that you shouldn't judge someone by whether you'd sleep with them and that the prime minister sounds a bit like Rik Mayall. You gave me a wall of text and hallucinated me watching Owen Jones videos.

Worse than ChatGPT.
(, Tue 20 Jun 2023, 16:35, Reply)