You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1605957 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post The messaging is all over the place and comically sensationalist.
'Allowing the extraction of new oil and gas resources in the UK is an obscene and genocidal policy that will kill our children and condemn humanity to oblivion.'.

- Well, no. Barring industrial accidents, nobody is going to die as a direct result of new gas and oil extraction in the UK. Likewise, prohibiting extraction of new oil and gas in the UK isn't going to magically spare humanity from 'oblivion' and global net demand for fossil fuels certainly isn't going to miraculously reduce just because the UK Government decides not to tap any new sites.

The rest of the mission statement is equally as sensationalist and melodramatic:
"the slaughter of billions of the poor", "Climate collapse will mean the end of workers’ rights, women’s rights, all human rights.", "no war-style mobilisation.".

The entire thing seems to have been written to specifically target those vulnerable members of society who are already suffering with severe climate anxiety by deliberately exploiting their fears.

I'm in complete agreement that we should try to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels - we literally won't have a choice in the coming decades, and the bigger a head start we get on the transition, the better. But these radicalised fuckwits are doing absolutely nothing but negatively shifting the public's perception of eco-activism.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 9:50, Reply)
This is a normal post Their messaging may not be the best,
but their goal is -
"We need to cut energy demand by insulating Britain and rethinking how we travel including providing free public transport everywhere. This starts by switching government subsidies from dirty fossil fuels towards clean energy, transport and insulation."

Not "You the public should stop consuming petroleum based products". Not sure how misrepresenting that helps.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 10:21, Reply)
This is a normal post
I mean they chose the name "Just Stop Oil". There's no way you could read that and assume they want you to stop using oil is there?
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 14:22, Reply)
This is a normal post True.
Sadly there's also no way someone could easily find out what they actually stand for, prior to expressing an opinion on it.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 14:40, Reply)
This is a normal post
Well if the name of your organisation is a demand, then it's not unreasonable to assume that's what you're demanding.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 17:11, Reply)
This is a normal post What should they be called?
And what actions should they be taking?
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 20:05, Reply)
This is a normal post You seem to me to be excessively optimistic
- just like you think they're being excessively sensationalist.

EVERYONE is going to die as a direct result of continuing to increase the extraction and use fossil fuels. Global heating means we already have parts of the planet less habitable than they were when I was a kid. In this century, the number of hurricanes per season is on average double what it was in the previous 150 years.

Yes, this needs to be a global solution, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't do anything until the whole world agrees to join in.

Holding the government - our policy makers who have the power to do give up funding the acceleration of the crisis - holding them to ransom by taking action against the establishment and against the ignorant continuation of the status quo, that's their approach.

You want something more polite and convenient? The eco-protest bloc doesn't have the extreme wealth that the oil companies do, so lobbying is on a massively uneven field. When there are fossil fuel advocates at the international climate change conference - that's fucking obscene.

Sometimes I think that if shutting down infrastructure and protesting at establishment functions isn't enough - maybe the next step is to start assassinations of lobbyists, MPs, and oil executives? - but I imagine most people think that's a bit much, you know.

Anyway, here's a pic of a psychic mole to distract everyone. Feel free to throw tomato soup at the screen.

(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 12:30, Reply)
This is a normal post Of course, if the end justifies the means
then there was a global reduction in temperatures in the 25 years after WW2.

Just saying.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 13:18, Reply)
This is a normal post Obey the mole

(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 14:07, Reply)
This is a normal post Its says
brain mole mole
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 17:54, Reply)
This is a normal post yes
obey
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 19:53, Reply)
This is a normal post And I thought I was a bit extreme
by suggesting bombing oil refineries and coal fired power stations.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 14:41, Reply)
This is a normal post Excellent
Let's do a collab
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 15:12, Reply)
This is a normal post Although
- can we bomb them some way so they don't burn?
Mixed messages and that.
(, Wed 28 Jun 2023, 15:14, Reply)