Peter Stefanovic
(, Fri 29 Sep 2023, 16:07, Reply)
she says almost no illegal migrants paid more in taxes than they took from benefits. Peter Stefanovic then quotes a study talking about European migrants. which may have been the same study, but she says illegal and he says European. are they talking about the same cohort or is one of them blowing smoke up my arse?
(, Fri 29 Sep 2023, 17:27, Reply)
It would be reasonable to assume that most *actual* illegal migrants don't claim benefits, since they are not in the system.
(, Fri 29 Sep 2023, 18:00, Reply)
*i.e. been denied leave to remain and still remaining in the country. Entering the country without permission is not in of itself a crime.
(, Sat 30 Sep 2023, 1:19, Reply)
the illegal ones will be put in the 'mates of the government profit scheme' or, as they like to call it, temporary accommodation or shipped to Rwanda. From the government website, "People who enter the UK illegally will not have their asylum claim determined in the UK, and they will not be able to make a life here.". The government itself bars them from contributing.
The legal ones (the ones he calls European migrants) will just move here, get a job, and start taking advantage of the UK economy (by growing it and paying taxes).
Plainly, the solution is to let the illegal immigrants be legal immigrants, so they get a job and start paying taxes instead of being forced to languish on benefits in an asylum centre.
Then they too would contribute more than they cost.
(, Sat 30 Sep 2023, 16:30, Reply)
People can't be illegal.
It is not illegal to enter the country to seek asylum. There is no such thing as an illegal asylum seeker. An asylum seeker cannot be an illegal immigrant. An asylum claim can be rejected, at which point the claimant can be deported.
It would be illegal to enter bypassing passport control, or overstay on your visa - IF you don't intend to claim asylum.
It's not just invalid asylum claimants or illegal immigrants who are to be trafficked to Rwanda either. Your asylum claim will be processed in Rwanda. If your claim is valid you will *stay* in Rwanda.
(, Sat 30 Sep 2023, 18:00, Reply)
Actually processing their cases.
It’s mismanagement on an epic scale, and it’s all driven by the fear of being pilloried by the right wing press for increasing immigration numbers. Neatly ignoring the fact that behind every case is an actual human being.
Utterly immoral behaviour driven by craven cowardice.
(, Sat 30 Sep 2023, 18:18, Reply)
Visas granted in the year ending June 2023:
work visas (including dependants), up 208,295 (+63%) to 538,887
study visas (including dependants), up 165,968 (+34%) to 657,208, including sponsored and short-term students
The tabloids don't make a big deal of this, they only seem to make a stink about a relatively tiny number of asylum seekers arriving in small boats.
(, Sat 30 Sep 2023, 19:22, Reply)
They take half your money then point at some poor unfortunate and say "they're trying to steal a tenner from you".
(, Tue 3 Oct 2023, 5:42, Reply)
but she'd only give you an incompetent/dishonest proto-fascist politician's response.
Seriously it doesn't take much to gain a better understanding of our immigration and asylum systems than this peabrained deplorable. Just read the data here: www.gov.uk/entering-staying-uk/border-control
(, Sun 1 Oct 2023, 16:36, Reply)