brief snippets from an article. its a bit arty/sociology lecture, so apols if u cant stand this sort of stuff
also - woo me - a link i posted made teh newsletter!!
edit: have this: Obama with a 'fro and a Mr T
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 16:47, Reply)
I'm only a first year film+tv student so don't know enough to argue. But i think he might be overstating it a bit? Theres lots of interesting things going on culturaly at the moment, with social networking etc, but I don't think its evidence an entire cultural shift? the influence of interactivity on content is seriusly limited in my opinion, the effect of editing, and whole load of factors of Big Brother serve more to influence people's "voting" than their "voting" actualy has on the content of the show I would say.
I'm reading a book called "Understanding the Psychology of Internet Behaviour" by Adam Joinson at the moment for an essay I'm going to write (if you see me trying to get my self flamed on /talk and /mainboard in the next few days you might understand lol) The first chapter is about the history of mediated communication, stuff like romances between telegraph operators etc. Its interesting how much of what we see as modern and unique to our generation can be seen in other times.
From what ive been learning I'm a bit suspicious of big anouncments of cultural change and their positive/negative effects. As one of my lecturers points out, Plato hated the idea of writing.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 17:03, Reply)
Also the cover of the Philosophy Now next to the article about the death of postmodernism has an ironic reinterpretation of a 50s robot, which seems a bit postmodern. Also "participatism" sounds silly, but meh, maybe it'll catch on. Also here are some paintings of some monkeys in hats: www.lukechueh.com/paintings/monkeys-with-hat.html
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 17:18, Reply)
I'll be glad if it's dead, but there may be life in the bitch yet.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 19:11, Reply)
Although they both represent a broad paradigm shift, how each materialises into results depends on the medium. As an architecture student, I could go on all day about modernism and post-modernism, but I don't think it would apply to a large part of society.
I find his arguement especially flawed if you try and apply it to architecture. Sure, the subject is becoming more powerful in relation to the object with the internet etc, but in terms of how we experience the real (rather than virtual) world, there hasn't been much of a change. Architecture continues to be defined by the distinction between those who can afford to commission a building and those who use it. There's a whole world of Marxist arguements there, but I'll spare you...
My main problem with the quoted article is basically that, where he argues that there is a societal shift in author/subject relations with the world, I would argue that it's not a shift in the world per se, but just an increased exposure to the digital, which has always had author control at its centre. I wouldn't expect to see this control seep into many other areas of life (as they're still constrained by real world conditions) so I don't see how post-modernism can ever really die.
Though it's been dead in architecture for a while...
/mental splurge
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 19:52, Reply)
either reject Lyotardist narrative or conclude that class has significance. In a sense, several desituationisms concerning subcultural capitalist theory may be discovered.
The characteristic theme of de Selby’s analysis of the precultural paradigm of consensus is the collapse, and eventually the meaninglessness, of textual sexual identity. Lacan’s critique of subcultural capitalist theory implies that context comes from the masses, but only if Baudrillardist simulacra is valid. It could be said that an abundance of theories concerning a self-justifying whole exist.
Sartre’s model of subcapitalist material theory suggests that the Constitution is capable of intention. However, the subject is interpolated into a that includes narrativity as a totality.
Subcultural capitalist theory implies that truth is elitist, given that consciousness is distinct from culture. In a sense, Lyotard uses the term ‘Lyotardist narrative’ to denote the common ground between society and class.
In Queer, Burroughs reiterates subcultural capitalist theory; in Naked Lunch he denies Lyotardist narrative. It could be said that the premise of subcultural capitalist theory states that discourse is a product of the collective unconscious.
Several narratives concerning Baudrillardist simulacra may be revealed. But Abian implies that we have to choose between Lyotardist narrative and postmodern constructivist theory.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 20:35, Reply)
but you just summed up everything I hate about philosophical quoting.
With so many names dropped into such a short argument, I can't help but feel that there's a need to impress and/or give an impression of knowledge without demonstrating understanding. I may be completely wrong...you may understand the workings of your argument perfectly. Either way my point is: why do you need to quote so many people...if you have an opinion, why not state it. You don't need validation from established figures of philosophy to make a point.
What's your opinion? It'll be much more interesting that the quotation of other people's views. And probably more succinct too. As I say, nothing personal...I just have pet hate of philosophical masterbation. I like discussing things...but I can only engage if I know what's being said.
But I do have questions about what you said. Best to start from the beginning...The big question is did you mean your post in reply to mine? It doesn't seem to directly relate.
Secondly, when you say that we must choose between Lyotardist narrative and postmodern constructivist theory, are you implying that class does not hold significance in a postmodern constructivist framework or are you implying that postmodern constructivism forms a capitalist subculture (and the anti-marx implications this entails)? Also, to what are you refering? Architecture? Society? etc?
I guess I'm just asking for clarification... and plain english rather than a smoke screen.
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 22:23, Reply)
I lifted that from the postmodern essay generator - clicky
(I encountered enough of this sort of thing in literary theory to make me wary of it [and pseudointellectuals and pseudophilosophers] for life. The only serious/generous thing I can say is that the whole postmodern eclecectism thing is here to stay, and that isn't necessarily a bad thing. Scientific relativism (as in astrology being on an equal footing with astronomy in terms of truth value) can fuck right off though; moral relativism is fine, but only because moral absolutism was a crock of shit to start with)
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 23:03, Reply)
Modernism wasn't a reaction against romantacism- it was against realism
(, Fri 8 May 2009, 23:42, Reply)