Are you a QOTWer? Do you want to start a thread that isn't a direct answer to the current QOTW? Then this place, gentle poster, is your friend.
(, Sun 1 Apr 2001, 1:00)
« Go Back | See The Full Thread
You could argue that following orders to kill is provocation, and thus fits the original question.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:48, 1 reply, 16 years ago)
I wrongly assumed you could provoke someone else to do something to a third party, rather than provocation being a strict two-party affair (victim provoking assailant).
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:52, Reply)
but Wormulus is still right, they weren't provoked to kill, merely encouraged
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:53, Reply)
If there was a penalty for not going through with the task? (and assuming no prize for doing it)
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:54, Reply)
it might become coercion (though coercion is not a defense as it happens for murder) but it's still not provocation
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:56, Reply)
then you can offer a defence of duress to certain crimes. Not an unlawful killing though.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:57, Reply)
« Go Back | See The Full Thread