After reading this article linked to on the front page, I started thinking about the legal implications of what we do. I know nothing about law, so excuse me if I make an arse of myself. Anyway, as far as I can see, how can ANY image on the internet be copyrighted?! Surely once an image is placed on a public web site, it is public property. You can't just say that it is ok to look at an image, but you can't do anything with it.
If an image is on a pay-site, then fine, it should be left alone. But if an image is available freely on a web site, then it has been given to the public. As far as I am concerened corporations are just trying to make even more money for themselves by trying to sue people who use their images.
If this was real, material images, such as paintings, or magazine images then they should be allowed to be left alone. But digital images are different. There are not tangable, and for all intents and purposes, they dont really exist (hmm, not sure what I am talking about anymore...)
I think I will stop there, but do you see what I mean? Do you agree with me, or do you think the (evil) lawyers are right?
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 11:31,
archived)
If an image is on a pay-site, then fine, it should be left alone. But if an image is available freely on a web site, then it has been given to the public. As far as I am concerened corporations are just trying to make even more money for themselves by trying to sue people who use their images.
If this was real, material images, such as paintings, or magazine images then they should be allowed to be left alone. But digital images are different. There are not tangable, and for all intents and purposes, they dont really exist (hmm, not sure what I am talking about anymore...)
I think I will stop there, but do you see what I mean? Do you agree with me, or do you think the (evil) lawyers are right?
"It's so frustrating. I just paid £40,000 for these images of Liz Hurley. And tomorrow? They'll be scanned in, and be all over the web. And if I sue? Then I'll make the company look like an evil thing shitting on the small guy."
(Just to give you an opinion from the other side of the fence)
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 11:41,
archived)
(Just to give you an opinion from the other side of the fence)
but does this indicate that we are placing too much value on images? Yes, i know that a lot of hard work goes into images, by people like graphic designers (my sister is one, hence all the photoshopping software) and artists. But I think a lot of photographs are overvalued. They are taken by people who stalk celebrities and take pictures which they then sell for extortionate prices to tabloid newspapers. The value seems to be in the image rather than the person. (wow, that is surprisingly deep)
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 11:48,
archived)
the only lawer they could get to say anything on the subject works for "Womble Carlyle Sandridge & Rice. " for fuck sake. surley they are guilty of taking the name of a popular kids TV programme and combining it "illegally" with a bunch of other words such as the popular foodstuff "rice".
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 11:46,
archived)
and is still not clear, even if you do a quick course in this kind of internet law, as some people where i work did, you still have no fucking idea. There is copyright with digital images, but the proving that the image was yours is very difficult. There is no difference in law between images on a pay or free site, if the image was bought or originated by the people who own the site. You simply paying to go on the site does not mean you have bought the right to all the images on it. It also depends on what you do with it, if you scan a press image from a magazine and then use that to promote anything you are breaking the law. The same is supposed to apply to digital images, but the original proof of ownership is a very grey area. Of course with messing with them there is the extra deformation of charcter etc. areas as well.
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 11:51,
archived)
Without a doubt images shown on the web don't magically move into the public domain, they remain copyright.
There's not that much difference between a webpage and the side of a bus - it's just easier to pick the image up from a webpage (although I think Monkeon should have a crack at inventing some device for removing posters from the side of a moving bus).
I can guarantee that submissions on this board regularly break copyright laws.
Question is though - what effect does this have? Copyright is there to protect against others profiting from your work, right? Maybe not even profiting, but limiting YOUR ability to profit (like me giving away free something that you would normally sell).
But we're not doing that. We're not profiting from what we do, and we're not competing with them to distribute their products. A copyright holder could insist the images are removed from the board/website, but a legal copyright action would have to include a claim for damages, and there aren't any (maybe pride?).
I wouldn't disagree with the bloke who paid 40 grand for the pictures, and found them all over the web the next day (these presumably were not photoshopped, they were just doing the same thing as he was - showing a set of pictures). In that case his audience is being pinched by whoever nicked the photos.
But we don't do that.
There may be a very limited legal case against what we do (but not enough to make me worry for 1 minute), but the moral case like the Liz Hurley example doesn't apply. We're not doing that.
Alternatively I might be talking out of my arse, but I'm gonna carry on photoshopping.
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 12:12,
archived)
There's not that much difference between a webpage and the side of a bus - it's just easier to pick the image up from a webpage (although I think Monkeon should have a crack at inventing some device for removing posters from the side of a moving bus).
I can guarantee that submissions on this board regularly break copyright laws.
Question is though - what effect does this have? Copyright is there to protect against others profiting from your work, right? Maybe not even profiting, but limiting YOUR ability to profit (like me giving away free something that you would normally sell).
But we're not doing that. We're not profiting from what we do, and we're not competing with them to distribute their products. A copyright holder could insist the images are removed from the board/website, but a legal copyright action would have to include a claim for damages, and there aren't any (maybe pride?).
I wouldn't disagree with the bloke who paid 40 grand for the pictures, and found them all over the web the next day (these presumably were not photoshopped, they were just doing the same thing as he was - showing a set of pictures). In that case his audience is being pinched by whoever nicked the photos.
But we don't do that.
There may be a very limited legal case against what we do (but not enough to make me worry for 1 minute), but the moral case like the Liz Hurley example doesn't apply. We're not doing that.
Alternatively I might be talking out of my arse, but I'm gonna carry on photoshopping.
so i guess b3ta could be sued for that...
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 12:20,
archived)
For a long time now I've had the idea of creating a kind of "secondary" internet. Almost like a P2P network, only with webpages instead of software as the interface. The idea is, this new net would embrace the attitude of sharing and free trade. There would be no corperate sites, no pay sites, no pop-ups (banners, used sparingly, might be acceptable), just a lot of good-natured nerds like us creating and sharing in peace. A established group of hackers could "police" things by farking up anybody violating the rules and sending their page to hell.
It's just a pipedream of course, but it's a thought...
(,
Tue 12 Mar 2002, 12:10,
archived)
It's just a pipedream of course, but it's a thought...