You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1601705 | Random

This is a normal post Let's be real, though.
Giving the public completely unfettered access to end-to-end encrypted means of communication was never going to end well.

The idealism of "well, we should be able to have unregulated access to completely private, secure communications" is not that far removed from "well, I shouldn't have to lock my doors when I leave the house", or "well, I should be allowed to get absolutely blackout drunk at a house full of people I don't know without the fear of being raped!" or "I shouldn't have to worry about my bike being nicked if I leave it unlocked outside the Post Office for 5 minutes!"

But we do have to do these things. Because cunts aren't just running the world, they're also living in it along side us. And like it or not, some of those cunts are going to take advantage of freely available end to end encryption in order to abuse kids, traffic slaves, plan terror attacks and generally just be horrible bastards. As is usually the case, the actions of the few ruin it for the many.

I don't prescribe to this 'Big Brother' conspiracy bollocks that a lot of the privacy campaigners seem to leverage, though. As much as these campaigners might throw their hands up in despair at the claims of "I've have nothing to hide, so I have nothing to worry about", it's the truth. Out of the 40+ Million users in the UK, what would make me so amazingly special that somebody at the Met/GCHQ would decide to snoop in on my conversations? 90% of my Whatsapp communication consists of myself and the ex sending farts to each other via voice note. The other 90% is mostly my elderly dad asking why his iPhone isn't getting emails.

As for the "Ah! But what if the Government turns into a fascist dictatorship and starts making normal, nice stuff illegal after banning encryption?!". Well, the encryption ban will be the least of our fucking worries in that scenario.

We can't have it because as a society, some of us can't be trusted with it. Is that unfair? Probably. But that's just the way it is.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 14:43, Reply)
This is a normal post It's not that though is it
It's that if you make e2e breakable then it'll be a cybercrime free-for-all and those fuckers are scary enough as it is. I'm not sooooo worried about big brother but Kim Jong and Putin will be stuffing buildings with MIT graduates to get their hands on our messages. Christ almighty, it's bad enough with people killing themselves and paying over their life savings to online crooks as it is, if they could really get access to all our private conversations and address books it'd be end of fucking days.

No, not a good idea to make it crackable. Not a good idea at all.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 15:26, Reply)
This is a normal post The people most likely to fall victim to cybercrime are the people for whom e2e provides the least protection.
There's absolutely a risk of the withdrawal of e2e making the general public more vulnerable to blackmail/extortion schemes, but in reality, the people most at risk from these kinds of schemes are those with the most at stake (government officials/diplomats/celebrities/etc).
There are far easier ways to extort Steve the successful local business owner without having to resort to phone hacking.

As for the espionage thing? That's been going on for generations. And we're just as complicit in it as those evil red state commie bastards are. There is no higher ground on that playing field.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 15:51, Reply)
This is a normal post MOST at risk, sure
but atm we can take measures to reduce the risk and e2e helps to protect people from fraud. I don't want that to be diluted. Fucking hell, I've been on the end of some very sophisticated scammers and while I like to think I'm pretty savvy I got very close to being emptied out.

There are far easier ways to extort Steve the successful local business owner without having to resort to phone hacking at the moment, but if it becomes easier to hack his WhatsApp messages the cost/benefit ratio could easily see Steve being rinsed. AND what about the e2e on all his apps on his phone? If those become crackable he may as well go back to keeping cash under the mattress.

Poor Steve.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 17:57, Reply)
This is a normal post And also if you close your eyes and wish really hard
Maths still doesn't go away
(, Sun 19 Mar 2023, 7:35, Reply)
This is a normal post Giving the public encryption?
The public created it.

Your belief that if you have nothing to hide you have nothing to fear is just a fascist cliche at this point. It's a belief shared by authoritarians and idiots. Everyone has something to hide.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 15:49, Reply)
This is a normal post "It was created within the public domain, so now it must stay in the public domain!" Really, birb?
Your belief that everyone has something to hide is just a self-soothing cope at this point. It's a belief shared by nonces and wife beaters. Not everyone has something to hide.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 16:00, Reply)
This is a normal post Who are you quoting?
My point was that it wasn't given by government, so the idea of "Giving the public completely unfettered access to end-to-end encrypted means of communication..." is fundamentally flawed. It's just not how it works.

Your straw man has half a point though. It is very hard to remove anything from the public domain in the broadest sense. Individual governments can claim ownership over the rights to this or that, and try to control distribution going forward, but governments cannot control maths. Cryptography is considered a fun hobby by some, and we have an internet now. Somebody somewhere will always be looking for a more complex puzzle to solve.

Not all of those people will end up working for government security services.

Not all government employees with access to your information can be trusted either.

You have several things to hide. Your PIN, sort code and account number for a start. Any behaviours that could incriminate you, or could be used to blackmail or harass you.

Also I notice you're arguing that you have nothing to hide while hiding behind a pseudonym.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 16:49, Reply)
This is a normal post "Not all government employees with access to your information can be trusted either"
By definition they spy on people in exchange for money. Seems pretty shifty to me....
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 17:53, Reply)
This is a normal post Not half as shifty as the army
Bunch of hired killers who hate foreigners.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 17:59, Reply)
This is a normal post There are lots of cases of local council employees with grudges
abusing their ability to access personal data. There's usually such a story reported in Private Eye.

Also there have been some pretty high profile cases involving Special Branch and SIS fucking innocent people over.

Also our government is corrupt, immoral and incompetent, and they are ideologically opposed to maintaining our human rights.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 18:11, Reply)
This is a normal post Christ you’re a humourless individual.

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 19:59, Reply)
This is a normal post Whooosh

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 20:32, Reply)
This is a normal post Anyone who doesn't use their real name as their b3ta username must be a paedo terrorist.

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 18:10, Reply)
This is a normal post Quite right, Mr. Power.

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 19:17, Reply)
This is a normal post Grasping, mate. Grasping.
The only incriminating behaviour that I indulge in is illicitly downloading television episodes and movies via bittorrent. Hardly the kind of behaviour I have to worry about going public.
I don't do drugs, I don't drink, I don't break the speed limit. I have no ongoing personal vendettas and all my previous ones have been put to bed. I've never taken part in, accused nor convicted of a crime relating to a sexual offense and I've never been abusive to a partner. Physically or otherwise.
For the last 10 or so years I've been clean as a button. You clearly find this hard to believe (likely because you clearly have a very sordid side yourself - the compulsive virtue signaling is blatant over-compensation), but I can promise you that there is literally nothing in my past that could be used against me. For anything.

My name isn't a secret either. Fucking obviously.

There very well could be videos and images of me taking part in sexual activities in various states of undress on the devices of exes and good friends from years past. But I honestly couldn't give a shit about that stuff getting out, either. Most of us have done something similar and I have a well proportioned penis. Certainly nothing I'd be ashamed of and I don't have aspirations of beginning a career where that kind of material being ending up in the wild could pose problematic.
(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 19:33, Reply)
This is a normal post That's what a massive paedo would say...

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 20:31, Reply)
This is a normal post I've just emailed this whole thread to CEOP

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 20:42, Reply)
This is a normal post well proportioned penis

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 23:10, Reply)
This is a normal post People as naive as you need the protection of people as paranoid as me.

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 20:34, Reply)
This is a normal post Oh, and my name is Craig David.

(, Fri 17 Mar 2023, 21:32, Reply)
This is a normal post Yeah the pedos will stop using it immediately if it's made illegal
They sure don't want to be on the wrong side of the law. No siree.
(, Sun 19 Mar 2023, 7:33, Reply)
This is a normal post Let's get real
you're a cunt
(, Thu 23 Mar 2023, 9:26, Reply)