Intimidation and violence for one. I personally would have prefered them to be small hand grenades instead of eggs. But that is not really good for freedom and the rights of people to have opinions, even if they are wrong or unpopular.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:42, Reply)
If there were, I'd be wronging someone by correcting their misapprehension.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:47, Reply)
everybody has a right to an opinion, but like Brian Clough, I also believe in discussing those opinions and agreeing I am right.
Educating people isn't wrong; silenceing them without explantion is, if that makes sense.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:50, Reply)
The person whose position is indefensible ought to abandon it, though - or both participants, if both turn out to be untenable.
And you're simply wrong about there being a right to an opinion, since opinions can be mistaken. I can't make sense of the idea that you have the right to be mistaken, as I mentioned above.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:56, Reply)
I am firmly in the camp that believes: What you say is wrong, but I will fight to the death for your right to say it.
What you seem to be saying is, if you ran B3ta you would now be deleting my posts, because I am wrong.
Would that be a good thing?
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:01, Reply)
i offer your father 10 camels for your hand, 15 for a leg.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:06, Reply)
I think that there's a good reason to allow all kinds of argument on all kinds of thing. That's not because you (or I) have a right to your beliefs, though: exactly the opposite, in fact. The virtue of disinterested rational analysis of a claim and argument is precisely that it allows us to discern where we've made mistakes.
Once you've identified a mistake, I think that there's a duty that you owe yourself to correct it.
That is: no beliefs, opinions or claims are sacrosanct. They're all open to a kicking. Those that are better founded will live to fight another day. That's not because you have a right to them, though, and the moment they're found to be faulty, then they have to go.
I prize argumentative and intellectual rigour and integrity above all else. I don't care what you think; I do care about your reasoning.
In fact, that's the only thing about which I care.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:06, Reply)
why not? why do we not have the right to believe whatever we want? i thought this was a democaratic and free country? maybe im wrong. i think anyone has the right to hold any beliefs, whatever they may be. im shure the HRA gives us this right. and to communicate these beliefs.
altho i do agree all beliefs should be held up to scrutiny, i dont agree others must necessarily hold their beliefs up to scrutiny if they dont want to.
but please explain why we have no right? i am confused by this. i believe we have an a priori (? is this the right phrase?) right to hold whatever beliefs we want and think what ever we want. you may as well say you cannot write any story you want.. interestingly, you can hold any religious beliefs you want courtesy of the HRA.
funny that i believe the same as you in many regards: (eg would be equality, anti-religion, anti-goat-bullshite etc) but differ on this!
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 19:19, Reply)
and if you don't have rights to any opinion we better get the thought police in.
Most things are not certain and even if they are, it can turn out that they were in fact different. So those who were mistaken end up being right but they had no right to be right at the time.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:06, Reply)
Eh?
I'm all about thought police if by that you mean the ruthless purging of unsound arguments. I think that it's virtuous always to keep our own thoughts under scrutiny - it's part of a clear head. (I suspect you mean something more prescriptive - but I'm not going to rise to that.)
It's just because we're in a situation of uncertainty that claims to a right to belief are false. They could be wrong. And if it turns out that they are, then there's a duty to get rid of them.
That's not incompatible with wide ranging opinions in practice (although if we achieved certainty about something, then there'd be no room for diversity, with no loss of freedom implied thereby. You're no less free for being forced to believe that 2+2=4: indeed, it's adherence to certain rules of reason that serves to guarantee intellectual freedom. Without them, there'd be a horrible mess...)
Home time. I won't be able to reply to any reply until later - if at all.
:(
Just as /links was getting fun, too...
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:14, Reply)
I've a HUGE pile of work to do, and twatting around on b3ta is a much more attractive option....
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:19, Reply)
I mean people in general, in case you thought I was directing that at you individually.
The 'Personal universe' I speak of is the summation of each person's life experience and personal context through which they live their lives and interact with the rest of their universe.
2 people can both be absolutely right in conflicting beliefs and neither belief is mistaken due to the fact that it is correct in the personal universe of that person. There is no global correctness. Only things that have been mostly agreed upon as being defined the same, like colours and numbers.
When it comes to using words that have more than one meaning in the dictionary all bets are off, let alone translations of words that may or may not have any word that really means the same, or nearly the same.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:22, Reply)
They're evil fuckers, but they were elected. If you think its okay for someone to assult people you disagree with, then why is it not okay for them to assult you? And more to the point, the BNP are getting WAY too much publicity over a small victory as it is, stop enabling them. The more this is done, the more sympathy they gain, and the more coverage they will get, playing the victim card every time.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:48, Reply)
I'm not convinced. It makes too many assumptions about the disinterestedness, rationality, education and insight - the practical wisdom, if you will - of the electors.
Nor do I see why the mere fact that a policy is popular lends any weight to its being desirable. It's possible to have a majority desiring something abhorrent, and, that being the case, I'm not sure that there'd be any virtue in giving it to them.
No, I don't have any worked out alternatives. But in a world as complex as the one in which we live, I just don't buy the idea that mere popularity is all that good a way of forming policy decisions.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 15:54, Reply)
says it all. No; our system isn't perfect, but no-one has come up with anything better that I'm aware of.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:03, Reply)
For what it's worth, I'm all for revisiting and bastardising elements of Rousseau and Kant, with a bit of Plato and Aristotle thrown in.
That seems like a start.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:09, Reply)
Its FAR from perfect (because its an imperfect world), but its better than pretty much any other form of government. Democracy ISN'T mob rule, because it works within a framework of laws. Parties break those laws, and they should, and hopefully will be brought up for it.
I realise I'm horribly optimistic about all of this, but you have to have some ideals, even when the reality of them sorta sucks.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:14, Reply)
If a law is good because it's popular, then the moment it stops being popular it's no longer a good law - and so it's always at the tender mercy of opinion, however strange or undesirable that opinion might be.
If it's good because of some other factor, then why appeal to its popularity at all?
It's like a political version of the Euthyphro dilemma.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:17, Reply)
to say I am not familiar with you last sentence. But get on with your work! You can tell me another time.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:22, Reply)
Is the team selection right, which is why Clough selected it? Or is it right because it was selected by Clough?
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:35, Reply)
although philophosy isn't my strong suit. (I'm quite good at bullshit though). I'm more into psycology to explain the human condition: Maslov, Van Voight, Jerry Springer, Ant and Dec.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 16:48, Reply)
it makes you sound like a sixth former who wears DM boots.
You wrote this all over my Facebook profile with a bunch of stuff about how you'd rip up your ballot paper, and how the voters' views were worthless, and then at the same time you wrote "fears the BNP will get in" as your status and prompted people to sign an online petition.
Hello, this is the real world and practicality is a useful way to survive it.
(, Tue 9 Jun 2009, 17:02, Reply)
